Wrongful Arrest for Breach of Bail: Surrey Police Pay £5,000 After Electronic Tagging Errors

Photo of an electronic ankle tag.

In this week’s blog post, I explain how a series of errors by the Electronic Monitoring Service and Surrey Police led to my client’s wrongful arrest and detention for an alleged breach of bail. Despite the original breach notification having been withdrawn, police officers arrested him, causing considerable distress. Following our investigations and legal proceedings, Surrey Police agreed to pay £5,000 in compensation plus legal costs, highlighting the serious consequences of administrative failures and poor communication within the criminal justice system.

Electronic Monitoring Service and Police Errors Lead to Another Wrongful “Tag” Arrest

This week’s blog concerns a case in which a person whose bail conditions were being monitored by an electronic “tag” device lost his liberty as a result of human error and lack of joined up thinking – reminding us once again that technology is only as good as the human beings at either end of it.

Electronic Tagging in the UK: How Bail Conditions Are Monitored

In the UK criminal justice system, a “tag” is a colloquial term for an electronic monitoring device, usually worn around a person’s ankle, which enables the authorities to monitor their compliance with conditions imposed by a court or other lawful authority, such as the Prison or Probation Service. In that sense, it is a descendant, in this digital age, of the “ball and chain.”

Electronic tagging is used principally in three circumstances:

  • Bail: To monitor compliance with conditions imposed on a defendant released on bail, such as a curfew or geographical exclusion requirement.
  • Sentencing: As part of a community order or suspended sentence order, for example to monitor compliance with a curfew requirement.
  • Release from prison: To monitor compliance with licence conditions or conditions of early release, including Home Detention Curfew.

GPS and Radio Frequency Tags: Understanding the Difference

There are two principal types of electronic monitoring:

  • Radio-frequency (RF) tagging: Usually monitors whether a person is present at a specified address during prescribed hours. It does not ordinarily provide continuous location tracking.
  • Global Positioning System (GPS) tagging: Records the wearer’s geographical movements and can be used to enforce exclusion zones, location restrictions or other conditions.

News reports this very week suggest that Thomas Markle, father of Meghan the Duchess of Sussex, has been detained in Florida for allegedly removing just such an “ankle monitor”. The case I am about describe to you concerns a profoundly unfair detention, in which the fault lay with those policing, not wearing, the device.

Wrong Electronic Tag Fitted Following Magistrates’ Court Bail Hearing

On 7 August 2025, my client Curtis attended a hearing at Guildford Magistrates’ Court for a criminal matter. At the end of the hearing, he was granted bail with a residence and curfew condition.

On 8 August 2025, representatives from the Electronic Monitoring Service (EMS) – that ‘franchise’ of the criminal justice system currently administered by the private company Serco, attended Curtis’s home to fit a monitoring device: however, apparently because of unclear instructions from the Court, they fitted the wrong type of device – a GPS rather than a Radio Frequency tag.

I am duty bound to report that Serco’s maladministration of the EMS is nothing new – exactly the same catalogue of clownish errors occurred when the service was in the hands of their predecessors Capita Plc, leading me to ‘christen’ it the “Electronic Mistake Service”.

Electronic Monitoring Service Errors Lead to a False Breach of Bail Report

On 19 August 2025, the device showed as being of low battery. Serco issued a Section 9 Breach Notification statement to Surrey Police in respect of this on 21 August 2025.

Serco subsequently realised that they had fitted Curtis with the wrong type of device; on 31 August 2025, they emailed Surrey Police to inform them that the Section 9 statement should be “rescinded” and no action taken. The following day, Serco representatives attended my client’s property in order to change the device from a GPS model to a RF model.

Surrey Police Arrest Innocent Man Despite Withdrawal of Bail Breach Notification

Notwithstanding this, on the morning of 2 September 2025, PC Crowley and several other officers of Surrey Police arrived at Curtis’s house and arrested him for “breach of bail.” Curtis’s representations as to the true state of affairs, and the fact that the device had been changed only the previous evening, fell on deaf ears.

Wrongful Arrest and Detention Cause Distress to My Client

Upon arrival at the Police Station, Curtis made the same representations to the Custody Sergeant as he had to PC Crowley. Upon noticing the visible distress that my client was in, the Sergeant asked PC Crowley to verify the breach with EMS.

According to the custody record, the circumstances of arrest were that:

“The tagging company has informed that there has been a breach of tag and that the tag has been left uncharged for 16 hours”.

Curtis requested to be seen by a health care practitioner due to a worsening of his mental health brought on by this situation.  In the meantime, he was processed and placed into a cell where he remained for several hours.

Eventually, at approximately 13:00, Curtis was released from his cell and told that there had been a mistake on the part of Serco. He was then escorted home, distraught and on edge as result of his experience.

Can Police Lawfully Arrest Someone for Breach of Bail Based on Incorrect Information?

When Curtis subsequently instructed my expert team and I to pursue a claim for wrongful arrest on his behalf, we were initially met with robust denials of liability from both Serco and the Police. Serco hid behind the fact that they had not actually arrested or detained Curtis; the Police hid behind the initial breach notification from Serco sent on 21 August, maintaining that it gave their front- line officers “reasonable suspicion” to arrest in accordance with Section 7(3) of the Bail Act 1976, and claimed not to have received any further message from Serco ‘countermanding’ this.  

Challenging Surrey Police’s Defence of Reasonable Suspicion Under the Bail Act 1976

Surrey Police’s response cited the low threshold of “reasonable grounds for suspicion” set out by Lord Devlin in Hussein v Chon Fook Kam (1970) AC 942:

“Suspicion in its ordinary meaning is a state of conjecture or surmise where proof is lacking: I suspect but cannot prove…it means there is an executive discretion.  In the exercise of it many factors have to be considered besides the strength of the case.  The prevention of further crime and the obstruction of police enquiries are examples of those factors.” 

If patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel, “Chon Fook Kam” is ordinarily the first refuge of the Police lawyer. They further pointed out that there are no “necessity to arrest” criteria applicable under the Bail Act, as opposed to a general arrest under the Police & Criminal Evidence Act, meaning that the arrestee has one less line of defence for his liberty than would ordinarily be the case.

Liability for all heads of the claim presented was therefore denied by all parties; it seemed as though the Police and Serco were happy to play a game of “tag – you’re it” between each other, in which my client would be the ultimate loser.  

Missing Emails Expose Failures in Police and Electronic Monitoring Service Communications

However, my team continued to do their due diligence on behalf of Curtis, and obtained the various emails from Serco to the Police which constituted both the breach report and the breach recission. In response and following investigation, the solicitors for Surrey Police asserted that the email address used by Serco was invalid and therefore not received. However, this gave rise to an interesting question: if Surrey Police had not received the rescind request, how was it possible they had received the breach report initially?  We therefore pressed for clarification as regards the notifications from EMS, and Court proceedings were commenced to increase the pressure upon our opponents.

The Police now advised that their investigations had confirmed that two EMS emails had been sent by Serco to two different Police email addresses. In both instances, one email address was invalid and the other was a valid Surrey Police email address. The first Serco email had been received and was actioned. The second Serco email, the crucial communication rescinding the initial notification although sent to both the valid and invalid email address, could apparently not be traced – in other words, the Police had no idea whether it had been received or not, or possibly lost due to a systems or human error at their end.

£5,000 Compensation Secured for Wrongful Arrest Following Electronic Tagging Errors

In the circumstances, the Chief Constable’s legal team finally agreed to enter into negotiations, and my colleague Alexandra Nelmes was able to secure a very satisfactory settlement of £5,000 damages for Curtis’s wrongful arrest, plus his legal costs.

We are left to reflect on a litany of errors. Incorrect/ malfunctioning equipment installed, emails sent to the wrong address and/or ignored – demonstrating seriously inefficient processes and lack of smart management, in which people’s liberty is left to fall down the cracks between the various bodies of a dysfunctional criminal justice system.

How you can help

Making specialist legal knowledge accessible is a core part of why I write this blog. If you believe that clear, independent information about police powers and civil liberties is important, I would greatly appreciate you taking a moment to leave a 5-star review. Each review helps ensure that those searching for answers can find this site — and the help they deserve. Thank you for your support.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the police. With over 30 years’ experience and a national reputation, he has successfully pursued claims against all 43 police forces in England and Wales, securing compensation for victims of wrongful arrest, unlawful detention and police misconduct. He is committed to holding the police to account and protecting individuals whose rights and liberties have been infringed.

Wrongful Arrest: £14,000 Compensation After Police Mistaken Identity

This week’s blog post tells the story of my client Michael, an innocent family man who was wrongly arrested at his home in the early hours after North Yorkshire Police failed to carry out the most basic identity checks. Despite obvious differences between Michael and the actual suspect, including a 15-year age gap, he was detained, fingerprinted and transported between police stations before the mistake was finally recognised. Following a lengthy and initially dismissive police complaints process, serious failings were acknowledged, and I successfully secured over £14,000 in compensation for his unlawful arrest and detention, plus legal costs.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

£14,000 damages for Mistaken Identity Arrest

This week’s blog post concerns yet- another wholly avoidable “mistaken identity” arrest, arising out of lazy and slip-shod “by the numbers” Policing – in which Police “intelligence” was used with anything but, even when those numbers didn’t add up.

Police Mistaken Identity: How an Innocent Man Became a Stalking Suspect

My client Michael was at the time of these events in 2025, 41 years of age, and resided in North Yorkshire with his wife and two young children. He is a man of the utmost good character.  

In April 2025, South Yorkshire Police (SYP) sent an email to their colleagues in North Yorkshire Police (NYP) requesting an “address check” on Michael’s home address – they were looking for a person who shared Michael’s first and surname, and who was suspected of “stalking his ex- partner” – but evidently did not know where this other person lived, as the email stated that the premises were only “a possible link to the suspect.” They had obtained Michael’s address from the Electoral Register. The suspect’s date of birth – which was certainly not identical to my client’s – was also provided by SYP.

SYP further informed NYP that if the suspect was indeed at the premises then “he will need arresting on suspicion of stalking” and provided details of the dates of the phone calls said to constitute this stalking.

Subsequently, two officers of North Yorkshire Police attended at Michael’s home and spoke to his wife, who confirmed that a man with the name and surname they were enquiring about did live here, and that she was his wife. One of the officers immediately replied that he was  “not convinced we’ve got the right address here.” Michael’s wife confirmed that he was at work, and asked the nature of the officers’ enquiry.  The same officer again replied to the effect that they were dealing with a matter for another Force, that they had “done research” but were “not overly convinced” that they “were in the right place” or that their “information is correct”.

Although she remained in the dark about what they wanted – indeed, from their comments, the officers themselves didn’t really seem to know what they wanted – Michael’s wife helpfully provided them with his phone number, and they then left.

Michael was naturally both confused and concerned when his wife then rang him at work to explain what had happened. Like a good citizen, Michael then left work early and proactively attended his local Police Station – only to be told that there was no record of why Officers wanted to speak to him. He also called the Officers on the contact number they had provided to his wife, but to no avail.

Wrongful Arrest at 2.30am: North Yorkshire Police Arrest the Wrong Man

Despite not knowing anything about why the Police were trying to reach him, Michael had really done his best to save both himself and the Police all the harm, heartache and wasted time, money and resources of a mistake and unnecessary arrest. Sadly, North Yorkshire Police were not on the same page.

That very night, at approximately 2.30am, Michael’s wife woke him in a state of alarm, saying she could hear noises outside: it was indeed “Blue Burglars.” Michael rushed down to answer the door, dressed only in his night-clothes, and was confronted by two NYP officers, including PC Potts – not the same pair his wife had dealt with earlier.

Michael explained that he had been trying to make contact with the Police “all afternoon”.  PC Potts explained that he was not aware of that, but that he and his colleague had been asked to attend and speak to Michael. Michael invited the Officers into the premises, as courteously as he could do in the circumstances, and understandably anxious that neither his neighbours nor his children be woken.

Unlawful Arrest: Police Fail to Explain the Grounds for Detention

PC Potts then crashed a horse-and- cart through the dictates of both common sense and lawful Police procedure: he summarily announced that Michael was now under arrest “on suspicion of stalking” and that “South Yorkshire have basically asked us to come here and arrest you”.  Michael was completely shocked and replied “stalking?” and then “who?”.  PC Potts replied “I can’t give you that information, all I know is that there’s an allegation that you’ve been stalking someone.  They’re purely named as victim on the log that’s been transferred from South Yorkshire”.

PC Potts failed to ask Michael to confirm his date of birth and further,  failed to give any detail as regards the alleged offence and thus prevented the Claimant from understanding the basis of his arrest or asserting/ proving his innocence.

In a classic “I’m just following orders” manoeuvre, PC Potts explained that my client would have to come with the Officers to Custody and that “South Yorkshire will come and deal with you at some point and all will be explained in interview.  They’ll explain the allegation”.

This failure to provide basic information about the arrest actually rendered it unlawful from the outset – but Michael did not know that. He compliantly and respectfully accompanied the officers, although he first of all had to endure the humiliation of dressing and then using the toilet whilst being supervised by one of the officers – as well as the worrying about the knock- on effect this was going to have upon his wife and children.

Detained, Fingerprinted and Transferred: The Consequences of a Mistaken Identity Arrest

Michael was then taken from his house to the distinctly unhomely surroundings of York Custody Centre.

The Custody Record stated that Michael had been arrested for “Stalking without fear/alarm/distress” and that the arrest circumstances were that “between 19 February and 18 April 2025, DP [the Detained Person] has made a call every day to the victim from a withheld number, with the intention of causing her distress.  Victim has identified the DP’s voice on the calls”.  The reason arrest was deemed necessary was to “allow the prompt and effective investigation, protect a child or other vulnerable person”.

Michael advised the Custody Sergeant that there had been a mistake and that he had no knowledge of, or any possible connection with, any stalking offence. However, his protestations were ignored.

Following this, Michael was obliged to remove his clothing and wear police issue clothing.  Furthermore, he was required to provide his fingerprints, a DNA sample and be photographed. This is the degrading “prisoner- lite” processing which all arrestees go through; making even the most innocent feel somehow stained with guilt. Even when you are released the ‘avatar’ of yourself as a criminal suspect, with all of your biometric data, lives on in the Police computer system – and may come back to haunt you even after your innocence has been proven; so here is another reminder to exercise your rights to delete that data if you prove your arrest to have been an unlawful one.

At 4.50am, Michael was then transported to Doncaster, and handed over to South Yorkshire Police.

Wrong Person Arrested: A Simple Date of Birth Check Exposes the Police Error

Only now did an officer – the SYP Custody Sergeant in charge of “receiving” Michael – take the elementary investigative step of checking my client’s date of birth against that of the man who was actually wanted: they did not match, whereas Michael is a 41 year old Yorkshire man, the actual suspect was a 26 year old Irishman.

In the circumstances, SYP now refused to take custody of Michael, and authorised his immediate release, with the Sergeant noting his Custody Record as follows –  

“DP is alleged to have stalked his ex-partner, however looking at the crime, the DOB is wrong, the wrong person has been presented to me.  I am refusing detention”.

Shortly before 6.00am, Michael was released and given a lift home, feeling both emotionally battered and completely bemused by this experience of Police investigative incompetence.  

Photo of letter from North Yorkshire Police.

Police Complaints: North Yorkshire Police Fail to Acknowledge an Unlawful Arrest

The final sour icing on the cake, however, was provided 7 months later by the response of North Yorkshire Police to Michael’s heartfelt complaint.

Entirely missing the true point of the complaint i.e his entirely avoidable and unnecessary arrest, a woeful case of “mistaken identity” and the trauma and distress this had caused to his wife as well, DCI Page addressed his response as if the only issue was the early hour of Michael’s arrest –

“There are sometimes operational reasons why arrests are made ‘out of hours’.  I will ensure feedback is provided to our teams regarding appropriate timings for arrests.  Your understanding is greatly appreciated.”

DCI Page was reminded of real issues at the heart of Michael’s complaint, but frankly couldn’t seem to have cared less. His response was simply an attempt at deflection and discouragement –  “If you are making a complaint against false arrest etc then this will have to be put in writing to Legal Services”.

Police Professional Standards Investigation Confirms Serious Failures in Arrest Procedure

Thankfully, Michael was not discouraged, and his persistence paid off when, after a further 6 months of investigation, DC Townsend of North Yorkshire Police Professional Standards Department concluded as follows –

“Within approximately one minute of arriving at the address, PC Potts exercised his power of arrest.  Critically, he failed to verify the date of birth of the individual encountered before taking that action.  Such a check would have been both straightforward and necessary.  The suspect sought by South Yorkshire Police was a 26 year old male born in 1998.  The Complainant was significantly older, being born in 1983, and was clearly established at the address with his wife and children.  PC Potts identified that he had a vehicle with a private plate.  Both his appearance and personal circumstances were plainly inconsistent with the details of the suspect recorded within the investigation.  These factors should have prompted immediate scrutiny and raised serious doubt as to whether he was the individual sought.  It is clear that PC Potts had not taken sufficient time to review the available information.  This is reinforced by the fact that he is unable to name the victim. These details should have been relayed to [Michael] at the custody desk for him to understand the offence to which he had been arrested.  

The position was further exacerbated during the custody process.  Prior to presenting the Complainant to custody, PC Potts obtained and recorded his date of birth.  This should have brought the discrepancy to his immediate attention.  Had the information contained within the originating report been properly considered, the appropriate course of action would have been to de-arrest the Complainant without delay and return him to his family.

Following the Complainant’s transfer to South Yorkshire Police, it was quickly established that the wrong individual had been arrested.  Unlike North Yorkshire, South Yorkshire Police appropriately reviewed the available information, declined to authorise detention, and ensured the complainant’s immediate release.  A request was then made for North Yorkshire Police to facilitate his return home.

At that stage, the complainant had been arrested from his home during the early hours of the morning, removed from his family, transported to York and then later transported again to Doncaster Custody by South Yorkshire Police, in a cage at the back of a police vehicle, and subjected to a wholly avoidable ordeal.  The response from North Yorkshire Police upon being informed of the error lacked the degree of ownership, empathy, and remedial action that the circumstances warranted.  Greater urgency and professionalism should have been demonstrated in addressing the consequences of the mistake and ensuring the complainant’s welfare.  The facts are clearly documented and did not require much time or consideration to understand, however were not only missed by North Yorkshire officers, but again by the collecting team from South Yorkshire Police upon [Michael’s] collection.

While it may be argued that communication between the involved forces could have been clearer, the essential facts were available and readily identifiable within the information provided to the arresting officer.  The key details, including the suspect’s date of birth, were plainly recorded and should have been considered before any arrest was made.”

False Imprisonment and Police Misconduct: Lessons from an Avoidable Arrest

Let me set out here the lessons to be learned from this case, that can benefit both the Police and the Public –

  • There existed no reasonable grounds to arrest my client for the offence of stalking; the suspect was 26 years old and had an Irish accent.  Michael was 41 years old with a Yorkshire accent. The arresting Officer failed to take obvious investigative steps that would have swiftly confirmed that my client was not the suspect including checking the suspect’s recorded date of birth against our client.
  • This, as NYP PSD belatedly acknowledged, prolonged an ordeal that could and should have been brought swiftly to an end. This incident did not just impose a severe emotional cost upon Michael and his family – it was a huge and self- imposed waste of Police time and resources (across two Forces).
  • Attitudes and mindsets are the fundamental problem here, and a lack of critical thinking: arresting officers need to acknowledge the huge personal responsibility upon them not to take away a person’s liberty if it can be avoided, rather than just looking at an arrest as another task to be completed; custody sergeants need to critically and independently examine each proposed detention; Police complaint handlers need to be “on the side” of the complainant until there is evidence to the contrary (in the same way they would treat a victim of crime), they need to adopt an open, not obstructionist approach.

 £14,000 Compensation for Wrongful Arrest and Mistaken Identity

I am pleased to confirm that I have recently settled Michael’s claim for over £14,000 damages, plus legal costs.

However, whilst the type of Police attitudes to the job which I have highlighted above persist –  including inadequate review of available information, insufficient verification of identity, and a lack of critical scrutiny during the custody process – mistaken and entirely avoidable arrests of innocent individuals are going to continue to regularly occur. The Police need to not just pay lip- service to the need for “organisational learning” about incidents like this, but truly take these lessons into their hearts and minds.

Until they do, I will be here to assist the victims of mistaken identity arrests such as Michael, to restore the balance of justice through compensation claims and continue to highlight these cases on this blog, to ensure they get the public attention they deserve.

My client’s name has been changed.  

How you can help

I publish these articles regularly to demystify police powers and to help people understand when those powers have been misused. If this post has clarified your rights or reinforced the importance of police accountability, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your review helps point others towards experienced representation at a time when clear guidance really matters. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a specialist solicitor in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police, with over 30 years of experience and a national reputation. Having successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales, he has extensive experience in challenging unlawful arrests and police misconduct. If you have been wrongly arrested, including as a result of mistaken identity or a failure by officers to properly investigate the facts, Iain can help you hold the Police accountable and secure the compensation you deserve

Police Assault in Birmingham: £16,000 Compensation for Two Broken Wrists

When a night out in Birmingham ended with West Midlands Police officers violently pushing my client to the ground, leaving him with two fractured wrists, he turned to me for help. Despite initially denying liability and insisting their use of force was lawful and proportionate, the Police eventually agreed to pay £16,000 in compensation plus legal costs. This case highlights the dangers of excessive police force and the importance of holding officers accountable when they abuse their powers rather than protect vulnerable members of the public.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

What To Do When You’re Drunk – But the Police Are Disorderly  

I have written before about how Police Officers, rather than making night-time city-centres safer places, can make them more dangerous for revellers enjoying the “night- time economy” by abusing the gulf in power which already exists between them and the public – a gulf only exacerbated by the (lawful) intoxication of many of the patrons of clubs, bars and restaurants.  

This week’s post addresses another such case in which officers of West Midlands Police committed the twin sins of automatically siding with bouncers/ security staff without knowing what was actually going on, and behaving with contempt towards those who are “under the influence.” 

Police Misconduct in Birmingham’s Night-Time Economy

In December 2024, my client Gareth went out with friends in Birmingham city centre. In the early hours, he was involved in an argument with security staff outside a fast- food restaurant, which degenerated into a short- lived scuffle; nobody was hurt, and Gareth’s friends were preparing to take him home when two Police Officers arrived on the scene. 

The Officers had apparently spotted the scuffle from across the street, but knew nothing more than that. They immediately zeroed in on Gareth, who was obviously drunk: he was slurring his words and staggering. He called one of the officers “Stupid” – but nothing worse than that. 

Excessive Force by West Midlands Police Officers Leaves Man with Two Broken Wrists

Within seconds, both officers had laid hands on Gareth and had started to not just tell him to leave – but to push him away. Rather than apply common sense and compassion towards someone who was heavily intoxicated (and unlikely to remember much in the morning), the officers were immediately physically aggressive to Gareth and continued to shove him, even when he had his hands in his pockets and was not fighting back. The risk of harm this created to someone who was already very uncoordinated and unsteady on his feet should have been obvious, but the officers continued their behaviour. Both of them simultaneously shoved Gareth in the chest, causing him to completely lose his balance and go sprawling backwards – landing heavily on the floor, with his wrists taking the bulk of the impact. 

Gareth quickly got to his feet – the adrenalin shock of what had happened, and the alcohol in his system, masking the seriousness of his injury. He left the scene shortly afterwards, in the company of his friends, and was not arrested for any offence.

The Devastating Consequences of Police Assault and Excessive Force

The next morning, however, Gareth found himself in extreme pain and attended A & E at Wolverhampton Hospital, where it was confirmed that he had in fact fractured both of his wrists in the fall. To his shock, he found himself travelling home from hospital with both of his arms in casts and slings – reduced to an almost child-like dependence on his mother and his partner, as he was unable to cook, clean, wash or even toilet himself initially without aid, as well as being in a great deal of discomfort. His eventual recovery took months, and he struggled with depression as well as physical pain during this time, with his work affected and sporting hobbies out of bounds. 

This is not the kind of “hangover” anyone deserves to awake to – certainly not one inflicted by the very people who are supposed to be reducing violence on our streets and keeping them safe for the vulnerable. 

Taking Legal Action Against West Midlands Police for Assault

Gareth turned to me for assistance, recognising my expertise in winning significant compensation for those who have been wronged by the Police in such situations – whether wrongfully arrested for “drunk and disorderly” offences and/ or in fact themselves the victim of “disorderly” and violent Police conduct– and I was able to offer him representation on a “no win, no fee” basis. 

When Is Police Use of Force Lawful and Proportionate?

In their initial response to Gareth’s claim, West Midlands Police tried to dispute liability – arguing that their officers’ use of force was “lawful and proportionate” in order to protect the Officers’ “personal space” and to “de- escalate” the situation, despite the fact that the only people ‘fighting’ were the Officers. 

In this response, the Police lawyers also displayed the same attitude which I believe is at the root of front- line Officers’ misconduct in such situations: a contempt for ‘drunken’ members of the public and a failure to recognise that officers should be here to help such people, wherever possible, not bully and insult them. That is the responsibility they have chosen to assume by putting on the uniform of a Police constable. 

Rather than thinking that describing my client as “intoxicated” and “unbalanced” and “stumbling” exonerated them, West Midlands Police should have realised that those words were an indictment of their Officers – who used force upon a man in such a condition, and as a result broke both of his hands. 

£16,000 Police Assault Compensation Settlement Despite Denial of Liability

Despite the Police’s promise that “no offer of compensation will be made” and threat that Court proceedings would be “robustly defended” when I pushed back upon their arguments, threatened proceedings and started assembling expert medical evidence to prove my client’s losses, they soon changed their tune. I advised Gareth to reject their initial offer of £7,500 and have now achieved a settlement for him of £16,000 damages, plus legal costs.

Police Officers Have a Duty to Protect the Public, Not Assault Them

The Police must police our streets with compassion, not contempt or casual violence towards those under the influence. Drunken people are not “fair game”, and if during a dispute or conflict situation only the Officers are fully sober and in command of their faculties, then they need to behave like it. 

My client’s name has been changed.

How you can help

Every post on this blog is grounded in real cases, real experience, and a commitment to holding abuses of power to account. If you’ve taken something useful from this article, or if you wish to support that broader aim, I would be grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Each review strengthens this work and helps others in need of straightforward, specialist expertise find their way here. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in  claims for police assault, excessive use of force, wrongful arrest and other forms of police misconduct.

With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Can I Claim Damages for My Partner’s Arrest?

Picture of a handcuffed man being taken into a police van.

Can you sue the Police even if you were not the person arrested? In this week’s blog post, I tell the story of my client Kathryn, whose partner was wrongfully arrested by Surrey Police in a case of mistaken identity, leaving her and their young children traumatised. Although Kathryn herself was never arrested, I was able to pursue an independent claim for compensation on her behalf, arising from the Police intrusion into her family home, interference with her right to private and family life, and her unlawful detention in a bedroom. Her claim has now settled for a substantial sum, demonstrating that the victims of Police misconduct are not always those taken into custody, and that innocent family members can have their own legal rights to compensation.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human. 

Wrongful Arrest: When Police Mistaken Identity Devastates an Entire Family

One of the worst nightmares to which a woman could awake would be to the knocking on the door of her house of Police Officers come to arrest her partner for rape. Unfortunately, this is exactly what happened to my client Kathryn, during Christmas 2025. 

Surrey Police Arrest an Innocent Man at His Family Home

My client, her partner Joe and their two young children were fast asleep in the early hours, when Joe and Kathryn were awoken by banging on their front door. Joe went to investigate and upon answering the door was faced by several Surrey police officers who told him he was under arrest for multiple offences of rape and conspiracy to commit rape. Hearing the commotion, Kathryn came to her bedroom door, where she was confronted by a female officer who would not let her pass and told her to wait in the bedroom. Kathryn therefore had to call out to Joe to ask him what was happening, and if he was ok – all the time conscious of how distressed her son and daughter would be if they awoke to this scene.

Police Search the Family Home Despite Evidence Challenging the Allegations

After approximately 10 minutes the female officer “released” Kathryn from the bedroom, and she was able to speak to Joe, who told her about the accusation which had been made against him. Kathryn was utterly shocked, but quickly realised that the allegations didn’t make sense – and tried to show the officers her partner’s work diary to prove that he couldn’t have been where they were alleging on the given dates. The diary was taken by the officers, but the arrest went on, with multiple officers searching all over the house, including the couple’s bedroom where their young son was also sleeping.

Eventually, Joe was escorted from the premises and was taken to custody, and all officers left the house.

The Emotional Impact of Wrongful Arrest on Children and Partners

Naturally, Kathryn and her children were left shocked and devastated and could not get back to sleep; nothing felt normal. Kathryn’s son kept asking if Daddy was going to prison. The trauma for the person “picking up the pieces” at home after an unlawful arrest, can be as severe as that of the person arrested.

Police Powers to Search a Home Under Section 18 PACE 1984

Later that day, two Surrey police officers returned with a “Section 18 search warrant”. This is not in fact a Court warrant, but rather an authorisation by a senior officer for constables to use the powers set out under Section 18 of the Police & Criminal Evidence Act 1984 to search the home address of a person who has been arrested.

 The officers searched the house and inspected Kathryn’s phone and her children’s electronic devices, but left without seizing anything.  

The Humiliation and Distress Caused by a Police Raid on Your Home

Again, this was not the end of Kathryn’s suffering; Joe remained in custody and Kathryn started to receive messages from neighbours who had seen the incident. They were asking if Kathryn was okay, and the receipt of these messages and the knowledge that the “Police raid” on her house had been witnessed, naturally caused my client extreme embarrassment and distress.

Mistaken Identity: Police Admit They Arrested the Wrong Person

Meanwhile Joe, who was so confused by events that he asked the custody sergeant at the Police Station if he was trapped in a dream, went through the custody process of being processed and interviewed with a solicitor present – before being told that this was a case of “mistaken identity” and he was released.

The Lasting Psychological Consequences of an Unlawful Police Arrest

Shame does not just attach to the guilty, and for a long time afterwards Kathryn felt that her neighbours were looking upon her with suspicion, and she “jumped” with anxiety every time there was an unexpected knock on the door. The sight of Police officers or cars would bring all the horrible memories of that night flooding back.

Can You Sue the Police if Your Partner Was Wrongfully Arrested?

Whilst it was obvious that Joe would now have a claim against the Police for wrongful arrest, when the couple consulted me I was able to advise Kathryn that she too had a right to claim.

Trespass, False Imprisonment and Article 8: Legal Rights of Innocent Family Members

In circumstances like this, the “non- arrested” member of the couple is highly likely to have a right to sue the Police for trespass to land and/or breach of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (the right to private and family life) and indeed “false imprisonment” – as happened here to Kathryn when she was detained in her bedroom under the orders of the female officer.

Compensation for the Family of a Wrongfully Arrested Person

A wrongful arrest is a devasting event which doesn’t just harm the person arrested, but also his or her close family: for Kathryn it was as if a part of her had been taken off into custody that Christmas night as well, and I was proud to be able to help her get restitution. Joe’s claim is presently ongoing, but Kathryn’s has recently settled for a substantial amount of money, plus legal costs. 

Specialist Solicitor for Wrongful Arrest and Police Misconduct Compensation Claims

I will leave no legal stone unturned to maximise a family’s recovery of damages for Police abuse of power, when a wrongful arrest affects not just a single person, but an entire household.

 My clients’ names have been changed.

How you can help

This blog exists to inform, empower, and reassure people who may otherwise feel overwhelmed when dealing with unlawful police conduct. If you’ve found this article helpful or informative, I would be very grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Your support helps me continue this work and, just as importantly, helps others find reliable, specialist advice when they need it most. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation. His expertise extends beyond claims brought by those unlawfully arrested to include innocent partners and family members whose rights have been violated by Police misconduct. 

Jury Trials in Claims Against the Police

In this week’s blog post, I examine the importance of jury trials in both criminal proceedings and civil claims against the Police, particularly those involving false wrongful arrest and malicious prosecution. Against the backdrop of controversial government proposals to restrict jury trials, I explain why the right to be judged by ordinary members of the public remains a vital safeguard against abuses of State power, and why preserving that right is essential to ensuring justice and accountability.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Government U-Turn on Plans to Restrict Criminal Jury Trials

In this week’s blog post, I am reflecting on one of the most prominent legal news headlines of the last few weeks through the lens of my expertise as an Actions against the Police specialist.

This was the welcome announcement that the “new” government of Andy Burnham is scaling back plans inherited from Keir Starmer’s premiership to severely restrict the right to Jury trials in the criminal courts of England & Wales. Jurors are the unquantifiable element in any legal case that helps to avoid complacency, to introduce a potentially “insurgent” factor into the halls of the establishment and to balance the “ivory tower” thinking of the typical judge with the common- sense of “the rest of us.”

Why the Right to Trial by Jury Remains Under Threat

Lord Chancellor Alex Norris announced at the Labour Party conference that having heard the strength of feeling on this issue, a decision had been made to “change course” and to scrap one of the most controversial elements of the Courts and Tribunals Bill, which would have created a Crown Court Bench Division with judges alone trying cases with potential prison sentences of up to three years. At the present time, almost all Crown Court trials are heard by a judge and jury.

The battle is not yet over, however, as other reforms proposed in the Bill, which would deny people the right to choose a Crown Court jury trial over a jury-less Magistrates Court trial (for so called “either-way” offences) continue to have government support.

Trial by jury of your peers is the hallmark of British democracy, and must be preserved; certainly not sacrificed for the expediency of balancing budgets. Trial delays and case backlogs can far more properly be dealt with by proper funding for our Courts. The money can and must be found elsewhere; Justice may wear a blindfold, but that isn’t an invitation to pick her pocket.

Can You Have a Jury Trial When Suing the Police?

Although this current debate centres around proposals to strip those accused of certain criminal offences of the right to a trial by jury, I also wish to highlight the importance of jury trials in the area of the civil law in which I practice. Because the truth is, that the bureaucrats of central government have already come once before for the right to jury trials, stripping it from the parties in civil litigation in all but a few areas of the law. One of those areas in which jury trials were preserved was actions against the Police – specifically claims for damages for false imprisonment (generally arising from wrongful arrests) and/or malicious prosecution.

This article which I wrote in 2013 extolling the virtues of civil jury trials – at a time when many of our current Police professionals were still in high school – remains as true now as it was then.

The Legal Right to a Civil Jury Trial for False Imprisonment and Malicious Prosecution

The right to elect for a jury trial in certain civil cases is enshrined in Section 69 of the Senior Courts Act 1981 (formerly called the Supreme Courts Act)and Section 66 of the County Courts Act 1984. These preserve the right, which was abolished for most civil litigants almost 100 years ago, to jury trial in the High Court and the County Court respectively for claims involving fraud, false imprisonment or malicious prosecution. That right must be exercised by making an application to the Court within 28 days of the service date of the Defence, in accordance with Rule 26.19 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

Why Jury Trials Are Important in Claims Against Police Misconduct

The protection of the citizen against the encroachment of the over-mighty State, or corruption amongst its agents, is therefore ensured by the twin rights to defend yourself against criminal accusations and sue for damages for any loss of liberty or malicious process involved in the former, with the integrity of both legal systems being reinforced by the right to elect trial by jury – jurors being the wildcards that no-one can take for granted. It is an inoculation against tyranny by an injection of the “anti” into the “establishment”, a healthy mixing of different backgrounds and perspectives.

Long may our age-old rights to jury trial be preserved, in both the criminal and civil courts, preserving the balance of power between the State and the citizen. I am their staunch defender, having seen with my own eyes on so many occasions how they help to make legal battles against the Police far more of a level playing- field.

Jury Trial or Judge-Only Trial: Which Is Best for a Claim Against the Police?

Of course, the existence of the right does not mean that it should always be exercised. I am an expert not only in successfully applying for jury trials, and winning claims against the Police put before a Jury, but also in analyzing which cases will benefit from jury determination, and which will not. Sometimes there are tactical reasons to elect for judge-only trials in claims for wrongful arrest and malicious prosecution; these are dependent on such issues as proportionality, time, costs, the character of the individual, the likely makeup of the jury,  and the nature and extent of the factual dispute between the parties. The important thing is that the right exists; for each of my clients, I will offer expert guidance as to whether or not it should be used.

Defending the Right to Jury Trials and Access to Justice

But as a matter of the utmost principle, lawyers, journalists and the informed public should circle the wagons, whenever government “reformers” threaten to come for our jurors.

How you can help

Every post on this blog is grounded in real cases, real experience, and a commitment to holding abuses of power to account. If you’ve taken something useful from this article, or if you wish to support that broader aim, I would be grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Each review strengthens this work and helps others in need of straightforward, specialist expertise find their way here. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation.

Can You Sue the Police for Excessive Force even though you’ve been Convicted

This week’s blog post addresses the question of whether you can still sue the Police if you have been lawfully arrested for an offence and, in fact, subsequently convicted of that offence. The answer to that question is yes, if the force used during your arrest can be shown to be excessive – but with an important caveat which I will go into below. In a nutshell, however, the old playground adage is correct: two wrongs don’t make a right.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Cheshire Police Officers Assault Man During Arrest Outside Chester Hotel

One night in December 2024 my client Dean was involved in a “public order” incident in a hotel in Chester (for which he later pled guilty). However, when four officers of Cheshire Constabulary arrived to arrest Dean, the incident had already calmed down and Dean was merely standing outside the hotel, smoking a cigarette.

Dean made no attempt to escape from the officers as they arrived and answered the lead (female) officer’s question as to his name. The female officer informed Dean that he was under arrest, to which he remained calm. Unfortunately, the three male officers in the squad now started to unnecessarily take hold of Dean’s arms and push him against the wall, as if they were spoiling for a fight. My client did not fight back, but verbally protested at what was being done to him and tried to free his arms from their grip – for which he was rewarded by one of the male officers grabbing him by the throat and then punching him, repeatedly and quite deliberately, in the side of his head.

Excessive Police Force: Punches, Kicks and PAVA Spray

A second officer then joined in with throwing punches, and between them, in the space of seconds, the male officers had kicked and forced Dean to the ground and sprayed him with PAVA (also known as “Captor”)  spray, leaving him curled up in a ball on the ground. The officers then proceeded to shout aggressively at him to put his “fucking” hands behind his back for handcuffing, whilst also kneeling on him and effectively preventing him from complying with their “request”.

The officers also now announced that Dean was further under arrest for “resisting arrest” and “assault Police” – neither of which accusations were true. Sadly, long experience has shown me how often the charge of “assault PC” actually means you have been assaulted by a PC.

Police Restraint, Positional Asphyxia and Verbal Abuse

When Dean, now lying injured and helplessly handcuffed, chest down on the ground (and therefore at risk of positional asphyxia), protested that the officers had kneed, kicked and punched him, the officers standing over him added insult to those injuries by berating him, calling him “a fucking dickhead”, a “dick” and mocking him for lying on the floor. Compassion and empathy was perhaps too much to hope for; but surely any degree of professionalism at this stage would at least have led the officers to bite their tongues. Apparently fuelled by their collective gang-think, they could not restrain themselves and echoed their colleagues’ aggression in a rain of brutality and invective.

Eventually, the officers picked Dean up off the ground, but owing to his injuries he struggled to walk, and so they ended up effectively dragging him to their van, where he was “caged” and driven to North Cheshire Custody Suite.

In light of his injuries, Dean was examined by a Health Care Professional (HCP) whilst in custody, and prescribed painkillers.

He was subsequently charged – and pleaded guilty to the public order offence – but was notably not charged with the alleged offences of resisting arrest or assaulting a Police Constable.

Photo of letters from Cheshire Police.

PSD’s Different Eyes  

The body worn camera footage of this incident was subsequently reviewed by Cheshire Constabulary’s “Professional Standards Department” and their partial and biased interpretation of what they saw prompts me to add further entries to “The Big Blue Book of Police Euphemisms” –

How Police Professional Standards Departments Describe Excessive Force

  • “Delivered strikes with a closed fist to the side of the head” – means “punched forcefully” as does “striking him with a closed fist to the side of his abdomen”.  
  • “Distraction strikes” – means “punched or kicked” and is terminology only ever applied to what Police Officers do to you, never vice versa.
  • “Poor language” – means swear and slur- words; what if coming from a civilian’s mouth would almost certainly be described by the Police as “abusive or insulting words” in the terms of the Public Order Act.
  • “Learning has been identified” – means, here is a large carpet under which we’re going to sweep this obvious misconduct, and pretend it’s something else.

Police Body Camera Evidence and the Failure to Identify Misconduct

PSD officers seem to think that a strangely decorous, almost medicalised description of a “beating” robs it of its force. I highly doubt that the same language would be used if the officers were describing two civilians fighting (or a civilian fighting Police). The fact that the first strikes were to the “red area” of my client’s head – literally putting him at risk of death or serious injury – was closed over with the woefully inadequate excuse that because the officer in question was tall, and was in close proximity to Dean “this was the only area he could reach.”

Needless to say, PSD concluded, despite the clear body camera evidence, that there was “no indication of misconduct in this case” and despite the fact that the female and one of the male officers were trainee officers. Notably, it was not these two “students” who commenced or committed the most egregious violence upon my client but the two experienced officers who were supposed to be setting an example for them. But all PSD could think to advise the officers was “consider how they write up use of force forms [to] offer more detail and justification” and to think about “how the public would perceive” Dean being grabbed by the throat.

In other words, PSD signed off on the officers’ use of force as lawful and proportionate and advised them on how best to ‘mask’ it from scrutiny in the future.

Cheshire Constabulary Admits Liability for Police Assault and Battery

If matters had been left to lie there, this would have been a travesty of justice, but thankfully Dean had instructed my firm to represent him, and I and my colleague Alexandra Nelmes secured an almost immediate admission of liability from Cheshire Constabulary. It was conceded that whilst lawfully arresting my client, the four officers had unlawfully assaulted and battered him.

Why the Police Complaints System Needs Urgent Reform

Once again, I offer this glaring disparity between the apparent assessment of Professional Standards that there was no wrongdoing by the officers, and the confession by Police legal services that there was as all the evidence that is needed to prove the moribund and corrupt nature of PSD departments and the need for urgent reform of the Police complaints system.

Is It More Difficult to Sue the Police for Assault if You are Convicted of a Crime?

Notwithstanding the quick concession of liability by the Police on the facts of this particular case, the Court rules do make it more difficult to sue the Police if you have been assaulted by them in the course of an arrest for an offence of which you are subsequently convicted.

Section 329 Criminal Justice Act 2003: The Grossly Disproportionate Force Test

The general law relating to Police use of force is that it is unlawful unless it is “necessary, proportionate and reasonable”. However, Section 329 of the Criminal Justice Act 2003 changes the criteria in cases when the force has been used against a subsequently convicted person; in such cases it is much easier for the Police to avoid liability because the law says they only have to compensate you if the force they used was not just unreasonable but “grossly disproportionate.”

Why Specialist Police Assault Solicitors Are Essential Following a Criminal Conviction

This is a much higher legal hurdle to clear in order to succeed in your claim, as I have explained in previous blog posts, and why in such circumstances you should always instruct a real specialist such as myself.

£15,500 Compensation Secured Following Unlawful Police Assault

I am very pleased to report that we have recently concluded Dean’s claim for damages in the sum of £15,500, plus his legal costs.

What I can’t confirm is whether Cheshire Constabulary have taken any of the lessons of this case to heart; and in particular whether the trainee officers involved have been appraised of the outcome – or left to continue their careers under the impression that “might makes right”  and “my officer wrong or right” are the central codes of British Policing.

My client’s name has been changed.

How you can help

This blog has grown through the trust of readers and clients rather than through aggressive marketing or paid promotion. If you feel this article offers genuine insight or practical value, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your feedback plays a meaningful role in helping others identify experienced, specialist advice when it counts. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales, challenging unlawful arrests, excessive use of force and police brutality. Even where an arrest is lawful and results in a criminal conviction, Iain has the specialist expertise to hold officers accountable for unlawful violence and secure rightful compensation for victims of police misconduct.

When Can Police Arrest a Child at School? 

Photo of a police officer leading a child to a police van.

The High Court judgment in Clarke v Chief Constable of Northumbria Police reinforces the strict safeguards governing the arrest of children, particularly at school. I examine why the Court found the 16-year-old Claimant’s arrest, handcuffing and detention unlawful, the importance of the necessity test under PACE, and the principle that Police must treat the arrest of a child as a measure of last resort.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

School Arrests and the Rights of a Child

If “an Englishman’s home is his castle”, then all the more so should a person’s childhood be respected as a stronghold against Police interference, violence and deprivation of liberty.  Of course, there are occasions when, just as the Police in extremis need to force their way into a person’s house, so a child must be arrested to prevent real and imminent harm to themselves or others; but even when reasonable suspicion of a crime exists, the arrest of a child should be the exception and not the rule.  The traumatising affect of arrest upon a young mind must never be underestimated.

Police Powers of Arrest and the Special Protection of Children

As we enter the ‘new school year’ I am caused to reflect upon a recent High Court decision which strongly reinforced the presumption that arrest powers should not be used against children – particularly censuring the arrest of a child at their place of education.

I have written at length on this blog about how the legality of an arrest is not just contingent of there being objectively reasonable suspicion of an offence – it must also be shown to be objectively necessary that the person be arrested in order for that offence to be properly investigated,  or to protect people from immediate harm – and nowhere is the issue of necessity more stringently regulated than when it is a child who is under suspicion. 

Corey Clarke v Chief Constable of Northumbria Police: Unlawful Arrest at School

The case of Corey Clarke v The Chief Constable of Northumbria Police [2026] EWHC 747 (KB) was an appeal to the High Court from the County Court, in which the Claimant was seeking to overturn the lower Court’s finding that his arrest at school, when he was only 16 years old, was lawful.

The Police investigation in this case related to alleged sharing of sexual images. 

On the morning of 9 November 2018, Corey was arrested at his High School in Sunderland (Southmoor Academy), handcuffed, and placed in the cage section at the rear of a marked Police van and driven to Southwick Police Station.  Approximately 7 and a half hours later he was released under investigation.  He was never charged with any offence. 

When Is It Necessary for the Police to Arrest a Child? 

The alleged necessity for 16 year old Corey’s arrest was said, by reference to the necessity criteria set down in Section 24 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 (PACE), to be as follows –

  • S.24(5)(d) – to protect a child or other vulnerable person;
  • S.24(5)(e) – to allow the prompt and effective investigation of the offence (specifically in this case, by an interview to obtain evidence by questioning).

But were the necessity criteria actually satisfied on the facts of this case, and especially considering the Claimant’s young age?

To properly consider this, it is necessary to look at another part of the PACE legislative framework – the Police Codes of Practice.

PACE Code G and the Arrest of Children at School

PACE Code G (Arrest Powers) provides as follows –  

1B Juveniles should not be arrested at their place of education unless this is unavoidable.  When a juvenile is arrested at their place of education the principal or their nominee must be informed. (This same injunction also appears in PACE Code C, Treatment in Custody, at note D11)

2C for a Constable to have reasonable grounds for believing it necessary to arrest, he or she is not required to be satisfied that there is no viable alternative to arrest.  However, it does mean that in all cases, the Officer should consider that arrest is the practical, sensible and proportionate option in all the circumstances at the time the decision is made. 

The High Bar of the Police Arrest Necessity Test

The appeal Judge, in ultimately finding in favour of Corey, stressed that whilst reasonable suspicion of an offence is a relatively low hurdle for the Police to clear and therefore “a reasonably thorough investigation is not a pre-requisite for reasonable grounds for suspicion” the essential second test of the legality of an arrest – the test of objective necessity – is “a high bar”.  (paragraphs 45-46 of the Judgment of HHJ Hanbury). 

Why Police Must Take Particular Care Before Arresting a Child

In emphasising the “Very particular care” which is to be taken before arresting a child, HHJ Hanbury referenced a case about which I have blogged previously in exactly this context –  ST v The Chief Constable of Nottinghamshire Police [2022] EWHC 1280 (QB) (26 May 2022)  – There is to be specific consideration of the fact that the arrested person is a child.  It requires an assessment of whether a less intrusive step than arrest and detention is a practical alternative.  ST was a case in which the child was arrested at 5.30am, when he was asleep at home. 

The Children Act and UN Convention: Arrest as a Last Resort

The Judges in both the present case and ST highlighted Section 11 (2) (a) Children Act 2004 which requires the Police to have regard for the need to safeguard and promote the welfare of children, and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child which provides at article 37 that the arrest of a child is a measure of last resort.

All other realistic practical alternatives must therefore be given adequate consideration before the arrest of a child is contemplated, and particularly an arrest at the child’s school.

Why the High Court Found Corey Clarke’s Arrest Unlawful

HHJ Hanbury set out the following factors at paragraphs 52 – 58 of his judgment, in support of his decision to rule in favour of Corey and declare that his arrest was unlawful, thereby amounting to false imprisonment –

  • A search warrant was a less intrusive measure which would have been more consistent with Corey’s welfare and best interests.
  • In accordance with PACE Codes C & G there must be a presumption against arresting children at school, and such an arrest must only occur “if it cannot be avoided”.  This is not a total prohibition on arrest at school – but it is getting very close to it.
  • The arrest in this case was “harsh and avoidable” – Corey did not have his mobile phone with him.  It was clearly unnecessary to arrest him at school to obtain a phone which he did not have.  No other children were at risk, because Corey had already been taken aside by staff into a separate room.
  • It was therefore neither unavoidable nor the “last resort” to arrest Corey.  Merely to consider alternatives to arrest was not enough – generally the arrest of a child at his or her school will be unreasonable, unless it is completely unavoidable.
  • Here, as noted above, Corey had already been taken to another room away from the rest of his class.  That was uneventful.  The staff had powers of search in relation to students.  Corey’s grandmother was involved in the investigation and her assistance was available. (She had recently attended a meeting with the school about this matter and subsequently cooperated with the search of her home, where Corey lived, and where the Police found and seized his mobile phone and iPad). 

Unlawful Arrest, Handcuffing and False Imprisonment of a Child

As the arrest of Corey was unlawful, it automatically followed that his handcuffing and subsequent 7 hour detention were also unlawful. Thus did the High Court correct the initial error and misapplication of the law by the County Court, and reinforce the protection of children from arrest.

Compensation Claims for Children Wrongfully Arrested by the Police 

My services in seeking civil justice restitution from the Police have been called upon by the parents of many wrongfully arrested children during my decades long legal career and I have a significant number of ongoing cases involving children subject to arrest, handcuffing – and some cases even more violent uses of Police force. Significant mental trauma and long-term psychological harm can be caused to teens who are ‘criminalised’ by being subjected by the Police to the dehumanising arrest process, particularly when that arrest takes place in the humiliating and embarrassing venue of the child’s school.

The Arrest of a Child Must Be a Last Resort

I therefore hope for the sake of countless other parents and children that the Police finally remember the strictures of their own Codes of Practice, the principles of English jurisprudence and the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child – and learn from the lesson of this Appeal Judgment to make the arrest of children truly a “last resort”.

 How you can help

Making specialist legal knowledge accessible is a core part of why I write this blog. If you believe that clear, independent information about police powers and civil liberties is important, I would greatly appreciate you taking a moment to leave a 5-star review. Each review helps ensure that those searching for answers can find this site — and the help they deserve. Thank you for your support.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police including cases involving the unlawful arrest, handcuffing and detention of children and young people. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales, challenging unlawful arrest and other abuses of Police powers and securing rightful compensation for his clients.


£15,000 Compensation for Wrongful Arrest After Police Mistaken Identity

I recently secured £15,000 compensation for Chloe Cannon after serious police investigative failures led to her wrongful arrest for GBH in a case of mistaken identity. Despite clear differences between Chloe and the real suspect, she was arrested at her nursery workplace, handcuffed, detained and transported to custody.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human. 

£15,000 Damages for “Mistaken Identity” arrest arising from Police investigative failures 

This week’s blog post concerns yet another “mistaken identity” arrest apparently arising from slip-shod Policing, compounded by their failure to uphold my client’s subsequent complaint, and deserves to be highlighted for both of those reasons. When most individuals are lazy or below-par in their job, the consequences for others are fairly limited; in the case of Police officers the consequences for others can potentially be catastrophic, as my client Chloe Cannon found out to her horror in July last year – because she was put at risk of losing her career. The stain and stigma of a Police arrest is not something that can be easily shrugged off, particularly not if you work in a position of trust with young children.

Wrongful Arrest for GBH After a Police Mistaken Identity Error 

Chloe, who was an apprentice “nursery nurse” was at her place of work, a nursery school in Essex, preparing to sit a vocational exam when she got the worst possible interruption – a visit from the Police. Chloe was asked to step outside by the officers, one of whom, PC Brockman, then informed her that she was under arrest on suspicion of conspiracy to commit “GBH”. In her shock, Chloe had to ask what GBH was. The officer explained the offence – Grievous Bodily Harm – and then went on to state that my client had been seen to “attend an address where a male has had his head stamped on and left himself in critical condition”. 

Handcuffed and Arrested at Work in Front of Colleagues and Parents 

Chloe was then handcuffed and searched – in view not only of her work colleagues but also parents attending the nursery. Chloe knew nothing about this unsettling accusation and said as much, to which PC Brockman told her to keep quiet and to keep her “thoughts and opinions” to herself. 

Chloe became as distressed as any person of good character, to whom adverse Police interaction is an alien experience, would be, especially when they genuinely know nothing of the subject matter of the accusation.

Detained at Southend Police Station Following the Wrongful Arrest 

She was then transported to Southend Police Station, still in handcuffs, and brought before the Custody Sergeant, “processed”, asked intrusive personal/ medical questions and “mug- shotted.” Her fingerprints, a urine sample and her DNA were taken; thus do the Police “medicalise” and data-mine the custody process, stripping detainees of their dignity as well as their autonomy in an environment which can be described as a hybrid between a prison and a hospital. This causes particular anguish if you know that you are innocent, but are totally in the dark as to why this is being done to you, or what the final outcome will be.

CCTV Evidence Raised Clear Questions About the Police’s Identification

After several hours, Chloe was formally interviewed and asked about her whereabouts on a given day, earlier that week. During the interview, she was shown CCTV footage of a car which officers said was similar to her own; in fact, it lacked a “spoiler” – a clear identifying feature of her own vehicle.

A Simple Tattoo Check Exposed the Mistaken Identity

Chloe was then returned to her cell, where she spent a miserable few hours, before she was visited by a Sergeant who, a little late in the day, asked if she had been spoken to about whether she had any tattoos. Chloe confirmed that she did, and described their locations. Shortly thereafter, she was taken from the cell and photographs were taken of the tattoo on her left thigh.

After more intolerable waiting, now into the evening, Chloe was interviewed for a second time and shown CCTV footage of a woman who was apparently the real suspect. When it was put to Chloe that she was the woman in the video, Chloe pointed out that this woman had a clearly visible tattoo on her right leg – which Chloe did not.

 The Serious Consequences of a Wrongful Arrest and Police Record

Shortly thereafter, she was released from Custody on conditional bail. As with many people, however, she found that her physical ‘escape’ was far from the end of her arrest ordeal. Events weighed heavily on her mentally, and she struggled to sleep, all the more so when the next day she had to explain to her employer what had happened – and as a consequence was suspended without pay. She had also missed her examination, delaying her qualification as a nursery practitioner. Chloe’s mind was racing with bad thoughts of what was going to happen next, particularly the effect that an arrest for “GBH” would have upon her career, as an Enhanced DBS check (Disclosure & Barring Service) can reveal arrests even if those arrests did not result in a conviction.

Picture of a letter from Essex Police.

Essex Police Confirmed Chloe Had No Involvement in the Offence

Things seemed to be going from bad to worse but, thankfully, the penny had finally dropped at the Police station and later that day Chloe received a call from DC Portbury to inform her that no further action would be taken against her. Furthermore, DC Portbury contacted my client’s employer by email and confirmed that she had  ‘no involvement in this offence and was in the wrong place at the wrong time’. 

Essex Police Reject Chloe’s Complaint About Her Mistaken Identity Arrest 

In a classic example of how useless the Police Complaints system is, when it comes to achieving answers, redress and accountability, my client’s prompt complaint about this matter was summarily rejected with the following “plastic smile” response from Essex Police –

“I hope this message finds you well. I am sorry to hear of your current dissatisfaction with Essex Police and distress being arrested has caused you.  Whilst I appreciate the inconvenience this situation may have caused you, it was unfortunately necessary to proceed with your arrest at the time, as you were a suspect in an ongoing investigation. I hope you have since been able to return to work and are now feeling in a clearer and more settled state of mind.” 

The Failure of the Police Complaints System to Provide Accountability

In other words: no explanation and no apology. Time and time again, the Police block-headedly fail to see complaints as opportunities, rather than obstacles; the opportunity to give an open and honest response to the complaint, and thereby to serve the public better, to improve their own reputation, and potentially reduce the number of compensation claims brought against them. Instead, they tend to treat every complaint as a challenge, obfuscate and argue, and use the word “sorry” as the first brick in a barricade between themselves and the public, rather than a bridge.

Essex Police Admit Liability for False Imprisonment and Human Rights Breaches 

As I have also written on this blog, time and time again, the fact that the Police themselves did not really believe their own denial was borne out by the fact that once I was instructed to send a formal letter of claim to Essex Police on Chloe’s behalf, liability was rapidly conceded – for False Imprisonment, Assault and Battery, Trespass to Goods and Breach of Chloe’s Article 5 right to liberty and Article 8 right to private and family life, under the European Convention on Human Rights.

How Basic Police Investigative Failures Led to an Unnecessary Arrest 

Quite clearly, Chloe’s arrest had never been “necessary” – and, if the Police had taken basic investigative steps to identify the correct suspect, could have been entirely avoided. Essex Police, it seems, were prepared to admit this when threatened with Court action – but not when they “merely” had the complaint of a distressed and innocent member of the public to deal with.

£15,000 Compensation for Wrongful Arrest and Mistaken Identity 

I have now secured for Chloe £15,000 damages from Essex Police for her wrongful arrest, and all the tribulation it caused her, as well as her legal costs. I am also assisting her with an application to ACRO Criminal Records Office, in order to have the record of this misbegotten arrest deleted.

Taking Legal Action Against the Police After a Wrongful Arrest

As there seems to be little chance of the Police changing their approach to complaints and claims any time soon, I’m pleased to confirm that I won’t be changing mine, either. 

The last word goes to my client, Chloe Cannon, who left this review on Trustpilot:

I was falsely arrested for GBH at my place of work. I was 22 at the time with no previous criminal record and was arrested by 5 police officers. I was held in a cell for 10 hours for a crime I had no involvement in. I was released on bail, for the next day, to be no further actioned and told that “there was nothing they could do as I was just in the wrong place at the wrong time”.
The person I worked for at the time got me in contact with Iain.
From the start, Iain was a great help explaining to me what I could and couldn’t do as this was something I had no knowledge of. Iain pulled apart their practice from that day to every minute detail. It took 14 months for the case to be solved and it was worth every day. Due to Iain’s unwillingness to back down in my defence, I was awarded £15000 for something that still affects me to this day.
I will forever be thankful for Iain.
Anyone who needs support and someone in their corner, should definitely get in contact with Iain.
Thank you Iain ☺️

How you can help

This blog exists to inform, empower, and reassure people who may otherwise feel overwhelmed when dealing with unlawful police conduct. If you’ve found this article helpful or informative, I would be very grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Your support helps me continue this work and, just as importantly, helps others find reliable, specialist advice when they need it most. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions for wrongful arrest and false imprisonment.

With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation.

If the Police have a Search Warrant for your HOME, can they also search YOU?

This week’s blog post addresses that headline question: and the answer is “probably not”.

Read on to find out more, in the circumstances of a case involving Humberside Police and a couple who maintain that they were the victims of malicious allegations of drug-dealing.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Humberside Police Execute a Drugs Search Warrant

My clients’ Claire and David reside in East Yorkshire and unbeknownst to them, Humberside Police applied for, and obtained, a warrant to search their home pursuant to Section 23 of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971, after allegations of drug- dealing from the premises were received.

One afternoon a few days later, the Police arrived at my clients’ house to execute the warrant. Claire was out shopping; David was in the back garden, in the middle of a telephone call with his daughter.

To David’s shock, a number of officers suddenly entered the garden and asked him to confirm his identity and the address, which he did. The officers then immediately handcuffed and detained him, with his hands to his rear.

A number of officers, including PC Calvert (a female officer), then entered the premises, while other officers kept David detained in handcuffs in the back garden.

PC Calvert then returned outside and informed David that there was a warrant for the address to search for drugs and asked:

“To save us the time, are we going to find anything in there, and if so, where will we find it?”

At this point David ‘confessed’ that he did indeed have a single joint of cannabis (nothing more) for his personal use, in a tub by his bedside.

The Police went upstairs and retrieved this and, for the avoidance of doubt, after a thorough search of the premises found no other illicit material whatsoever – no evidence of drug-dealing or drug-paraphernalia.

From a Search of the House to a Police Strip Search

However, it was not only the property which the Police searched: David was led inside, and his handcuffs were removed – but only, it transpired, so that he could comply with the officers’ subsequent instructions, which were for him to strip naked (or else force would be used against him).

David, in fear that force would be used if he did not comply, removed his t-shirt, trousers, shoes and socks and boxer shorts. When he was naked, the officers told him to squat; David complied. The officers then inspected the area of his genitals.

It does not take much imagination to understand how embarrassed, humiliated and degraded David felt by this.

Claire Is Also Subjected to an Intimate Strip Search

Unfortunately, the family’s degradation did not stop there, because at this point, David’s partner Claire returned home.

Claire was initially detained by the officers in the front garden, whilst they concluded their search of the house, but was then ‘invited’ inside by PC Calvert and also required to submit to a strip-search.

Claire had to remove her outer clothing, ‘flip’ her bra up for the officer to inspect her breasts, and then to also remove her shoes and underwear and to squat down so that the officer could inspect her genitals.

As with David, Claire was not physically touched during this process, but it was nevertheless a gross and intimate invasion of her privacy and hugely distressing, although she strove to remain calm and to preserve what shreds of dignity had been left to her by these occupiers of her home.

It was only after these two negative strip searches of my clients that the assembled Police Officers finally left the premises – and set about distributing notices to neighbouring properties boasting of their execution of the “drugs” warrant, without admitting that they had found nothing but a “spliff.”

The only action subsequently taken by the Police against either of my clients was a “cannabis warning” issued to David, which he signed.

Picture of letters from Humberside Police.

Can the Police Strip Search You When Executing a Search Warrant?

The action which Claire and David then wanted to take against Humberside Police was, however, an entirely different matter.

What Powers Do the Police Have Under a Misuse of Drugs Act Search Warrant?

When the couple approached me for expert legal advice on this matter, I was able to confirm that the Police had no power under the Warrant to search them – the warrant was specifically in relation to property, not people.

Section 23(3) of the Misuse of Drugs Act provides as follows –

“If a justice of the peace (or in Scotland a justice of the peace, a magistrate or a sheriff) is satisfied by information on oath that there is reasonable ground for suspecting—

(a)that any controlled drugs are, in contravention of this Act or of any regulations [or orders] made thereunder, in the possession of a person on any premises; or

(b)that a document directly or indirectly relating to, or connected with, a transaction or dealing which was, or an intended transaction or dealing which would if carried out be, an offence under this Act, or in the case of a transaction or dealing carried out or intended to be carried out in a place outside the United Kingdom, an offence against the provisions of a corresponding law in force in that place, is in the possession of a person on any premises,

he may grant a warrant authorising any constable … at any time or times within one month from the date of the warrant, to enter, if need be by force, the premises named in the warrant, and to search the premises and any persons found therein and, if there is reasonable ground for suspecting that an offence under this Act has been committed in relation to any controlled drugs found on the premises or in the possession of any such persons, or that a document so found is such a document as is mentioned in paragraph (b) above, to seize and detain those drugs or that document, as the case may be.”

PACE Code A and the Police Power to Search People on the Premises

This legislation has to then be considered through the lens of the Police Codes of Practice, set down as ancillary laws to the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, specifically Code A para 2.27 (b)  which specifically states that –

“The following powers to search premises also authorise the search of a person, not under arrest, who is found on the premises during the course of the search.. under a warrant issued under section 23 (3) of the Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 to search premises for drugs or documents but only if the warrant specifically authorises the search of persons found on the premises”. 

When Can the Police Lawfully Carry Out a Strip Search?

Yet further, para 3.7 of Code A provides that –

“Searches involving exposure of intimate parts of the body must not be conducted as a routine extension of a less thorough search, simply because nothing is found in the course of the initial search…”

In other words, the severe degree of personal intrusion that a strip search entails must be justified by a reasonable suspicion of “intimately concealed items” – which no officer here ever articulated any grounds or basis for believing my clients had upon them. Objectively considered, the suggestion that the couple were hiding drugs on their bodies seems ridiculous – David had been surprised whilst standing in his garden on the phone, and immediately handcuffed, whilst Claire had just returned from a shopping trip. Any such suspicion could not be based merely on the fact that the search warrant had been issued for the house: there had to be something more, in the actual facts of the encounter to base it upon – and here there simply wasn’t.

Why These Police Strip Searches Were Unlawful

Applying these strict rules of Code A to the circumstances of Claire and David’s case, it was clear to me that the Humberside Police Officers had, even if not committing trespass to land, had certainly committed trespass to my clients’ persons, by subjecting them to the strip- searches, and false imprisonment by detaining them whilst they did so.  The court warrant which the Police were acting under did not authorise the search of persons on the premises – and even if it had, a “strip search” is never something which can be undertaken on a speculative basis and the officers involved had no new information or grounds to justify them taking this draconian step.

Strip Searches, Trespass to the Person and False Imprisonment

A “strip search” is extremely adjacent to a sexual assault, and should never be used as crassly and casually as it was by the officers in this case.

Over £12,000 Compensation for Unlawful Police Strip Searches

Even more so than their homes, Englishmen’s (and women’s) bodies are their castles, and I was happy to take Claire and David’s cases on a “no win, no fee” basis and to sue the Chief Constable of Humberside, after he maintained that his officers had done nothing wrong. As the court proceedings progressed, the Police increased their offers of settlement from initial amounts of only £500 for each of my clients, until eventually total damages of over £12,000 were agreed, plus legal costs, shortly before trial.

Claims Against the Police for Unlawful Searches and Search Warrants

Read here examples of my considerable expertise in this area, and the significant awards of damages I have won for my clients in vindication of their “home rights”, even when the Police come armed with a Court Warrant –

My clients’ names have been changed. 

How you can help

Every post on this blog is grounded in real cases, real experience, and a commitment to holding abuses of power to account. If you’ve taken something useful from this article, or if you wish to support that broader aim, I would be grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Each review strengthens this work and helps others in need of straightforward, specialist expertise find their way here. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

False Imprisonment by a Magistrates’ Court: Protecting the Right to Liberty

Photo of a man behind bars.

This week’s post highlights how even the courts can get the law wrong when it comes to the fundamental right to liberty. After a Magistrates’ Court unlawfully detained my client during an adjourned bail hearing, and then wrongly treated his subsequent compensation claim as a mere complaint, my specialist team pursued proceedings against the Ministry of Justice, ultimately securing a substantial four-figure settlement plus legal costs.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Back to School: Suing the Court for Damages 

As we start a new “school year” I thought I would offer this reminder of how even the Judiciary and Court Managers, the supposed ultimate authorities of law and rules, sometimes needs to be taken back to school themselves.

When Can a Magistrates’ Court Detain Someone Under the Bail Act 1976?

My client Peter appeared before the Magistrates’ Court for a bail hearing pursuant to S.7(4) of the Bail Act 1976, which commenced at or around 15:45hrs.

At or around 16:50hrs, the Court adjourned the hearing to the following day, and Peter was removed from the courtroom and escorted to the cells.

The Magistrates intention was that Peter should spend the night in custody, pending resumption of the bail hearing in the morning – but I have written many times before about how jealously the law guards the fundamental principle of personal liberty, through both the tradition of the Common Law and the modern legislation of the Statute book, and how the powers-that-be, including the judiciary, can only take that liberty away from us in clearly prescribed and defined circumstances under the law. 

When an Adjourned Bail Hearing Becomes Unlawful Detention

The fact was, that this Magistrates Court had no power to detain Peter during an “adjournment” – this mistake was belatedly recognised by the Court, and Peter was then brought back before the Magistrates at 18.05hrs and the hearing resumed and continued until around 19.40, when Peter was released, subject to varied bail conditions.

Section 7(5) of the Bail Act provides as follows –

A justice of the peace before whom a person is brought under subsection (4) above may, subject to [subsections (5A) and (6)] below, if of the opinion that that person—

(a)is not likely to surrender to custody, or

(b)has broken or is likely to break any condition of his bail,

remand him in custody or commit him to custody, as the case may require, or alternatively, grant him bail subject to the same or to different conditions, but if not of that opinion shall grant him bail subject to the same conditions (if any) as were originally imposed.

Section 7 of the Bail Act: The Limits of the Court’s Power to Remand

In other words, the Court could only remand Peter in custody if it was conclusively of opinion “a” or “b” – and as it had as yet reached no opinion, it lacked any power to order my client’s detention other than for the duration of the hearing – and certainly not during a purported adjournment, when the hearing was explicitly not taking place. The Court either had to continue the hearing until it formed its opinion; or else order Peter’s release.

As neither of those things had happened between 16.50 – 18.05, the Court was liable for my client’s false imprisonment.

False Imprisonment by the Courts: When Judicial Errors Breach the Right to Liberty

The failure of the Magistrates themselves to understand the proper implementation of the Bail Act and the limitations of their own power, was then compounded by another ‘schoolboy error’ (and one which I see very commonly in my dealings with the Court Service). When Peter initially sent a letter of claim to the Court, alleging false imprisonment and a breach of his right to liberty under Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights, the Court’s Legal Team Manager acknowledged receipt of the letter, but stated that it would be treated as a “complaint” i.e not a formal claim.

This error by the Court – which occurs so often that I actually consider it may be a deliberate tactic – is particularly galling as it is the very Court Procedure Rules themselves which lay down the strict “pre-action protocols” governing how parties must present and respond to compensation claims. By treating the letter as a mere complaint, the Court could avoid the strict rules requiring a detailed response and pre-action disclosure of documents, and potentially ‘buy off’ the claim much more cheaply.

Taking Legal Action Against the Court for False Imprisonment

Thankfully, Peter knew his rights, and soon enlisted the representation of Elliot Smallshaw, another of the expert actions against the Police solicitors in my specialist team. 

Acting by way of a “no win, no fee” agreement, Elliot challenged the Court’s failure to properly address Peter’s claim, and when they denied liability, had no hesitation in advising him to bring civil proceedings.

Ministry of Justice Agrees to Pay Compensation for Unlawful Detention

I am pleased to confirm that this claim was swiftly settled, with the Ministry of Justice (who are ultimately responsible for the errors of the Magistrates Court) agreeing to pay Peter substantial damages, plus his legal costs.

Why the Right to Liberty Must Be Protected – Even for Short Periods of Detention

That this matter was about much more than a ‘technicality’ is reflected in the fact that this was a four-figure settlement; scrupulous respect for personal liberty and freedom from arbitrary imprisonment is the hallmark of a democratic society. False imprisonment by executive or judicial authorities should never have to be shrugged off in any circumstances, not even when it is ‘accidental’ and relatively short-lived; otherwise, we are at the thin end of a wedge of erosion against those liberties we hold so dear.

Peter was quite right to stand up for his rights in this situation, and I am proud that my team was here to help him teach the Court some valuable lessons – about how to follow its own rules. 

My client’s name has been changed

How you can help

This blog has grown through the trust of readers and clients rather than through aggressive marketing or paid promotion. If you feel this article offers genuine insight or practical value, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your feedback plays a meaningful role in helping others identify experienced, specialist advice when it counts. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Animal Rights Activist Unlawfully Detained By Police Wins Substantial Damages

Animal rights activist Gemma Barnes was unlawfully arrested by Sussex Police after she was assaulted during an anti-fox hunting protest in Lewes, despite officers initially treating her as the victim and arresting her attackers. This case highlights an important principle of police powers: officers cannot detain someone without lawful authority, and any arrest must comply with the strict requirements of Section 24 and Section 28 of PACE. 

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

The case of Gemma Barnes, an animal rights activist, recently attracted considerable media attention after videos were published online showing Police officers being rude and derogatory about Gemma and another activist, after Gemma had been arrested at a protest in Norwich in January 2023. The officers thought that they were talking “behind closed doors” – but they were in fact accidentally recording their conversation on Gemma’s confiscated body camera, which they subsequently handed back to her.  

The Police attitude showcased in these recordings does not make a pretty picture, and I think backs up the point I made in a previous blog post regarding Police behaviour towards protestors.

By way of a further illustration of that point, I can now talk about the circumstances of another unlawful arrest which Gemma suffered, at the hands of Sussex Police, and which is also a very useful reminder of a fundamental pillar of our civil rights: that the Police do not ‘out rank’ civilians and cannot detain us against our will without using a specific power such as stop-and-search or criminal arrest; and if they are purporting to arrest us, they have to explain themselves and provide key information in accordance with Section 28 of the Police & Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) 1984.

Unlawful Arrest at an Anti-Fox Hunting Protest in Lewes

In this particular instance, which occurred in December 2024, Gemma attended an anti-fox hunting protest on Lewes High Street. A rival “pro-hunt” group was in attendance.

The two protest groups were situated on either side of Lewes High Street and were separated by a line of Sussex Police Officers.

My client alleges that the pro-hunt group made threats of violence towards her group, and also racist insults, including calling a black member of the anti-hunt group a “monkey”, “big lips”, and imitating monkey noises in their direction.

Is It a Criminal Offence to Film the Police Making an Arrest?

At one point, one of the pro-hunt group was arrested by Officers. Gemma, who had been filming matters generally,  filmed this from a reasonable distance, but was nevertheless grabbed by the arm by an officer and threatened with arrest for “obstructing a Police Officer.”

To reiterate a point which has regularly been made on this blog: merely filming an arrest is not an act of “obstruction” and nor is filming a Police Officer a criminal offence.

After the protest had concluded, the anti-hunt group decided they would leave the area because they were concerned by the escalating bad behaviour from the pro-hunt group, and commenced walking back to their cars.

As the group were walking back to their cars, a large number of the pro-hunt group followed them. The pro-hunt group continued to shout insults and threats.

Police officers were still in attendance, and clearly identifying the threat, escorted the anti-hunt group back to their cars, which was the right thing to do.

From Police Protection to an Assault on a Protestor

Two female members of the pro-hunt group started to goad Gemma, including by asking her to stroke the fur coat which one of them was wearing.  When this failed to get a rise out of my client, the two women then physically attacked her – one by grabbing Gemma’s wrist and lashing out at her face, the other grabbing Gemma’s head, knocking her cap off in the process and pulling her hair. Gemma then pushed the women away from her, in an act of self- defence.

These events were witnessed, at close- range, by Police officers, who intervened to protect Gemma from the aggressors: both of the women who had attacked Gemma were arrested for affray.

Meanwhile, my client was escorted by Officers into a nearby bus shelter. She initially believed that this was simply for her protection, and when the officers asked if she would be willing to provide a statement, she confirmed that she would, and provided her personal details, naturally believing that she was being treated as the victim of the incident.

Can the Police Detain You Without Arresting You?

However, when Gemma then attempted to leave the bus shelter, she was stopped from doing so by PC Holmes. He informed Gemma that she was not allowed to leave, but did not give a reason; when my client challenged this, PC Holmes told her she was being detained under the “common law”. In this particular context, those words were meaningless, and certainly did not give rise to a lawful arrest.

Gemma, understandably, continued to protest that she was the victim, and that any detention was unlawful. In response, PC Williams now told her that she was being detained under “Section 24 of PACE” while they investigated “allegations that had been made”. This equally did not constitute a proper arrest: if you are being detained under Section 24 of PACE, which is the statutory power of arrest – the central tool in the Police’s crime-fighting arsenal – you have to be told what allegations have been made against you and what offence you are being arrested for, or the detention will be unlawful and will amount to false imprisonment.

When Is an Arrest Under Section 24 PACE Lawful?

Furthermore, any arrest will be unlawful unless it is based on reasonable suspicion of an offence, and a necessity to arrest you (as opposed to investigating the allegation by other means) and neither of those criteria were close to being satisfied here, in my opinion.

Gemma reiterated that she was the victim, and other witnesses confirmed her account; she pointed out that several of the Officers present had clearly seen the attack and that it would also have been captured on their bodyworn video cameras, i.e those officers who had immediately intervened to arrest the actual offenders.

Unfortunately, all of her representations fell on deaf ears, including her offer to attend a voluntary interview so as to negate any alleged necessity to arrest, and the bus shelter continued to be used as a temporary prison cell.

From Unlawful Detention to Arrest for Affray

Finally, at the end of approximately 10 minutes of this “non-specific detention” my client was informed by PC Williams that she was under arrest for affray (in relation to the incident in which she had actually been attacked) and she was taken hold of and conveyed to Eastbourne Custody centre, where the circumstances of her arrest were very inaccurately recorded as follows –

“DP [Detained Person] was a participant in a hunt taking place in Lewes and officers found her in a fight with another protestor in Tesco’s car park”

Gemma was there detained for approximately three hours, during which she was incarcerated in an actual cell, and interviewed under caution, before being released – no surprise – with a decision that “no further action” was going to be taken against her.

Why Was the Victim of the Assault Arrested?

It was notable that even the arresting Officer, in his written statement, confirmed that he, “initially thought the female with me was a victim”.  

No substance was ever provided in terms of exactly who changed PC William’s mind about this, or how they did it. Even if the women who had attacked Gemma had made “counter- allegations” against her, the fact remained that the incident had been fully witnessed by several officers who knew exactly what had happened.  

Police Counter-Allegations, Protestors and Unlawful Arrest

Reflecting on the totality of this incident, we can observe that the Police initially did do the right thing – swiftly intervening to arrest the women committing the assault, and protect Gemma. But matters took a turn for the worst from that point with Gemma rapidly moving from the status of being protected, to being imprisoned; surprising to say the least, given that the Police do not tend to reactively arrest victims simply because the original suspect has made a “counter- allegation” and all the more so in a situation in which the assault was witnessed at close hand by officers.

I suspect that this was a result of institutional antagonism towards activists, especially those seen as “anti- Police”, combined with the common Police tactic of unlawfully detaining people whilst “finding out what has happened”, as I addressed in detail in this previous blog post.

Compensation for Unlawful Arrest and False Imprisonment

This incident was sadly not Gemma’s first experience of unlawful arrest and mistreatment at the hands of the Police; but I’m pleased to report that, also not for the first time, she has with the help of our team, won a significant legal victory in response.

Ably represented by my colleague, actions against the Police specialist solicitor Alex Nelmes, Gemma brought civil court proceedings against Sussex Police who have, without admission of liability, now agreed to pay her substantial damages, plus legal costs.

As ever, I know that it is the sense of justice being achieved, and those who misuse power being held accountable, which is the bottom line for my client.

How you can help

Making specialist legal knowledge accessible is a core part of why I write this blog. If you believe that clear, independent information about police powers and civil liberties is important, I would greatly appreciate you taking a moment to leave a 5-star review. Each review helps ensure that those searching for answers can find this site — and the help they deserve. Thank you for your support.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Continue to GOWISELY:  A reminder of your rights in a Police stop-and-search

An unlawful Police stop-and-search is the subject of this week’s blog post, which I will use as a case study to illustrate the wrongs Police often commit in these situations, and the rights you have against them.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Unlawful Stop and Search by Greater Manchester Police

My client Pierre is a black man who was born in France, and speaks English as a second language.

One day in July 2023, he was walking home through Oldham, having attended his local gym, when two marked Police cars suddenly pulled up next to him and multiple Greater Manchester Police Officers alighted.

Pierre’s path was blocked by one of the Officers. My client attempted to walk around the Officer, however the Officer put his arm out to stop him from proceeding, and Pierre was then informed that he was being “detained” – but no explanation was given to him as to why.

Stopped, Detained and Handcuffed Without Explanation

Pierre accordingly decided to film the interaction on his mobile phone – something which I would always encourage people to do in such situations.

When Pierre protested that he needed to leave, he was grabbed by the Officers and forced against a wall. When he asked for the reason as to why he had been detained, the Officers told him to “stop talking” and to “relax”.

Still not having explained their actions – the Officers then handcuffed Pierre’s hands behind his back, causing him sharp pain and discomfort in addition to his shock and disorientation.

Pierre continued to ask why he had been detained, as was absolutely his right; eventually, he was informed that he was being detained under Section 1 of the Police & Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) 1984 for the purposes of a search, on the basis that he matched the description of someone who had been seen “making off” from the scene of a burglary. 

My client pleaded with the officers to let him go, saying that they had stopped him for no reason and were hurting him. He was now being held by approximately four officers, whilst another began to search him. Pierre continue to protest his innocence.  

Police Use of Force During a Stop and Search

Pierre was then taken to the ground, face down, by several Officers. His glasses were knocked off in the process, and one of the Officers put his knee on Pierre’s leg to pin him down.

My client was again told to “relax”, however he found this hard to do in the context of what was being done to him. The search continued whilst Pierre was being restrained on the ground in this manner.

One of the Officers again asserted that Pierre matched the description of someone who had committed a burglary. When he queried what that description was, my client was told that the suspect was “wearing a shiny coat and dark clothing.”

In response, Pierre pointed out that the coat he was wearing was not “shiny”. In the face of this vague and inaccurate assertion, with no other information being provided, Pierre naturally began to suspect that he was being detained not because of the colour of his clothing – but of his skin.

Can Police Demand Your Name and Personal Details After a Stop and Search?

The search was completed, and nothing had been found, as Pierre had no involvement with the suspected crime. An officer then asked for his personal details to “complete the search log.” Pierre protested – again, quite correctly in the eyes of the law, if not its officers – that he did not need to provide his details. At this point, despite the ‘negative’ search Pierre was still being held prisoner, restrained on the ground, and the officers were refusing to let him up.

Eventually, he was pulled to his feet, but the officers kept him in handcuffs, and continued to demand his personal details, including date of birth. The officers now threatened to take him to the Police station if he did not reveal his identity. They informed him that if he provided his details, he would be allowed to leave. My client knew that he was under no such obligation, and therefore continued to refuse.

Finally, Pierre’s resilience in defence of his rights was rewarded; despite their (unlawful) threats of incarceration, the officers removed my client’s handcuffs and allowed him to leave the scene.

When Does a Police Stop and Search Become Unlawful?

The law of England & Wales quite rightly respects, and jealously guards, the privacy and integrity of our persons. That is why the Police’s statutory powers to stop and search ordinary citizens in the course of their public business are hedged around and limited by a number of crucial rules, summed up by the “GOWISELY” mnemonic which outlines the criteria for a legal stop-and-search and the information the Police must provide to the subject of that search, in the interests of accountability and to prevent abuse of power, in accordance with Code A of the Police & Criminal Evidence Act. 

A popular article which I wrote some years ago about GOWISELY can be read here, but in summary the information the Police must explain to you in such situations is as follows –

  • Grounds – A clear explanation of the reasons for the Officer’s search, i.e why he finds you suspicious
  • Object – What the Officer will be looking for (e.g drugs, or stolen or prohibited items)
  • Warrant – Warrant card to be produced, if the Officer is not in uniform
  • Identity – The Officer must state their name and collar number  (except in terrorism cases, where the Officer can provide just his collar number)
  • Station – The Officer must identify the station at which he is based
  • Entitlement – The Officer must inform you of your entitlement to a copy of the stop/search record (which will be either handwritten or, increasingly, electronically recorded)
  • Legal – The Officer must specify the legislation under which he is searching you e.g the Misuse of Drugs Act or Section 1 of PACE
  • You – The Officer must clearly explain that you are being detained for the purpose of a search (and actually, although the spelling of the mnemonic requires this to come last – it should actually be the first thing you are told)

If the Officer conducting your search fails to comply with these behavioural steps then absent a good reason for such failure – such as fight or flight on your part – the search he is conducting of you is likely to be illegal and amount to false imprisonment and/or assault and battery, as well as trespass to goods if your belongings are taken/ interfered with.

What Lessons Can We Learn from this Case?

Applying these rules to the facts of Pierre’s case, the following key points stand out to me –

£12,000 Compensation for an Unlawful Police Stop and Search

Greater Manchester Police initially, and strenuously, disputed liability for Pierre’s claim, but, confident in our analysis of the evidence I and my expert team brought civil court proceedings on behalf of Pierre against the Chief Constable.

Although a Defence was filed apparently maintaining their denial, GMP proved not to have the stomach for the fight, and my colleague, actions against the Police specialist solicitor Alex Nelmes, has recently agreed a settlement of Pierre’s claim for damages of £12,000 plus legal costs.

So, if you are caught up in this kind of intrusive and violent Police search, remember your GOWISELY rights, record what is happening if at all possible, and come wisely – to this website.

My client’s name has been changed.

How you can help

I publish these articles regularly to demystify police powers and to help people understand when those powers have been misused. If this post has clarified your rights or reinforced the importance of police accountability, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your review helps point others towards experienced representation at a time when clear guidance really matters. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

FAIK OUT: Real Advice v AI Research

This blog post warns of the growing dangers of relying on AI for legal advice. Drawing on recent examples from my own practice, I explain how AI can wildly overvalue claims, misrepresent genuine case law, and confidently provide authorities which do not support the propositions for which they are cited. Although AI can be a valuable tool and offer significant productivity benefits, it cannot replace the judgment, experience and specialist knowledge of a solicitor. 

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

AI Legal Advice: Why Artificial Intelligence Is Creating Problems

The Economist magazine recently reported (“How AI is breaking the British State”, 6 August 2026) how the tide of AI generated content is beginning to cause problems for legal and governmental systems built for the “age of the post office and the telephone box”. The backlog in Employment Tribunal claims has risen by 55% in a year, as a result of “AI- fuelled claims”. There is a warning here for us all, as many of those claims will unfortunately have no merit, but the AI programme which a person has turned to for “advice”, such as Claude, ChatGPT or Co-Pilot, probably won’t tell them that, as it quite literally has no “skin in the game” and has a tendency to flatter and encourage its users – promising them that what they want is achievable, even when it isn’t.

When AI Gets Compensation Claims Wrong

By way of illustration of this, I can share some very recent experiences of my own. The first concerned a client who has a good claim against the Police for a wrongful “stop and search” incident – but who was led by AI research to wildly over-value his claim.

After medical evidence had been obtained in order to assess the psychological impact of the incident, my client informed me that his realistic estimation for total compensation was in the region of £150,000. Unfortunately, this was out of all proportion to his actual injuries and losses, and was clearly the result of his making an enquiry with an AI programme.

I, and two of my colleagues, who between us have around 100 years of litigation experience in the fields of personal injury and actions against the Police, in fact valued this client’s claim as being worth in the region of £10,000 – £15,000 i.e an entire order of magnitude less than the AI advice.

AI Cannot Replace an Experienced Actions Against the Police Solicitor

“Large Language Models” (AI) are not a substitute for the experience and depth of knowledge of a solicitor such as myself who has practiced in this field of law for over 30 years.  AI programs are notorious for misunderstanding, misquoting or indeed completely hallucinating the law and are designed to ‘please’ their users by telling them what they want to hear – even if what they are saying has no basis in reality.

AI Hallucinations, Fake Case Law and the Risks of AI Legal Research

Indeed, there have been well- reported cases of AI programmes feeding their users entirely made-up case reports, and advocates who don’t know better getting themselves into a great deal of trouble by seeking to rely upon these “Frankenstein” cases before a human (– well, probably-) Judge.

When AI Misinterprets Genuine Case Law: AXX v Zajac

Another of my clients referred me recently to two cases which AI had told him supported his contention that a vulnerable Claimant with psychiatric problems should be able to refuse examination by the Defendant’s medical expert on grounds of “re- traumatisation”, and could instead have the Court only rely upon the Claimant’s own, already obtained report, contrary to the age-old “equality of arms” presumption in litigation which is that both parties should be allowed to call upon equal amounts of expert evidence.

As it happened, these cases really did exist – but they really did not support the argument which AI was telling my client they did. One in particular was the case of AXX v Zajac [2022] EWHC 2463. Whilst AXX was indeed a vulnerable Claimant, who at one stage had been sectioned under the Mental Health Act, whose identity was anonymised for the purposes of the litigation, and who was suspected to have suffered a traumatic brain injury, the Judge in the case highlighted the importance of Claimants “cooperating with and speaking to medical experts for the purpose of expert reports for the Court” and went on to make an order that AXX had to make himself available for interview and assessment by the Defendant’s experts, and that if he did not and instead continued to refuse to engage with the Defendant’s medics then a “Stay or De-barring Order” could be imposed, effectively preventing the claim from proceeding.

So, the conclusion of that case was really the complete opposite of what the ‘cheerleading’ AI bot had led my client to believe it was.

The Danger of AI Telling Legal Clients What They Want to Hear

The root cause of this problem is the AI’s desire to please its user by providing them with material to support their argument, even when, in reality, that material simply does not exist. AI programmes are not people and have no sense of shame or morality; point out to them their error and they are simply likely to respond with an electronic shrug and Cheshire- Cat smile-  

“Good catch! You’re right to question that, I made it up – my apologies.”

Cold comfort for those who have thereby been misled in high-stakes civil or criminal litigation cases.

AI Is a Useful Legal Tool – But It’s Not a Lawyer

AI is a very useful tool, and can have real productivity benefits – but we mustn’t lose sight of the fact that it is a tool; effectively, it is a very sophisticated search-engine, it is not a true author or adviser as it does not understand, or indeed care about, the highly polished articles it produces and presents to you. Human intelligence in any field of expertise must remain the real deal and the last resort. I hope that this warning will help to prevent people with good cases self- sabotaging them by reliance upon swift, smooth, polished, but ultimately unreliable AI.

Also remember that you can generally spot an AI article, essay or letter by its almost invariable habit of adopting the following structure for its arguments: “[Something] is not X. It is Y” e.g “The future of legal isn’t fewer lawyers. It’s fewer decisions requiring lawyers.”

Watch out for such language, and superficially persuasive information which won’t stand the stress- test of reality. If you don’t, you may be in danger of TerminAIting your case, or as AI-Arnie might say:

“I don’t need your clothes, your boots, or your motorcycle.

I need all three of them.”

How you can help

I publish these articles regularly to demystify police powers and to help people understand when those powers have been misused. If this post has clarified your rights or reinforced the importance of police accountability, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your review helps point others towards experienced representation at a time when clear guidance really matters. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

£5,000 Damages for 5 Minutes Detention In Mistaken Identity Case 

This week’s blog post is an illustration both of how often the Police “arrest first and think later” when they believe their authority is being infringed, and the critical importance which the law of England and Wales places upon the liberty of the individual, such that even a mistaken arrest lasting for less than 5 minutes can attract significant damages.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Police Arrest the Wrong Person: Child Mistaken for His Older Brother

My client Lewis is a young black man who suffers from a receptive and expressive language disorder.  In the early hours of the morning, one day in March 2024, a large squad of Metropolitan Police Officers arrived at Lewis’ home address, intending to arrest Lewis’ older brother. 

There was a significant difference in appearance between the two brothers: Lewis was 16 years old, approximately 5ft 4in tall, had dreadlocks and was of chubby build and darker skin than his brother.

Lewis’ brother was 28 years old, approximately 6ft tall, had a receding hairline, was of slender build and of lighter complexion.

A Mistaken Identity Arrest at Home

Lewis answered the door to the Police Officers upon their arrival, his mother and elder brother being asleep upstairs.

The Officers demanded Lewis’ name; he was shocked and confused and asked what was going on.

Officers Ignored Clear Differences in Age and Appearance

Without attempting to explain themselves, or to properly consider whether this child was really the man they were looking for, two of the Officers then entered the house, grabbed hold of Lewis, pushed him against the wall and handcuffed his hands behind his back.

One of the Officers now informed Lewis that he was under arrest on suspicion of breaching a Restraining Order and making threats to kill. 

Lewis pleaded with the Officers that he was a minor and that they had the wrong person.  He told them his name.

Only now did the Officers start to make proper enquiries.  Some of them went upstairs and discovered Lewis’ older brother asleep in bed, arrested him and de-arrested Lewis.

Lewis’ older brother was then taken into custody.

Why the Arrest Was Unlawful

When Lewis’s Mum subsequently asked me to represent him I reviewed the evidence and was more than satisfied that the Officers had completely ‘jumped the gun’. 

They should have been aware from the outset that Lewis was not the person they were looking for, given the very clear disparity in the brothers age and appearance.  Sadly, they used their authority to bulldoze over Lewis’ personal freedom, traumatising and injuring him in the process, simply because he had not immediately answered their question.  This is a question which Lewis was not obliged to answer in any event; it should have been the Officers who were explaining to him their proper purpose at the house, not simply barking orders at a frightened child and expecting them to be immediately obeyed.

The Lasting Physical and Psychological Impact of a Wrongful Arrest

I investigated the impact that this incident had had upon Lewis, as I will never leave a stone unturned when ensuring that my clients receive full and proper compensation, and established the following –

  • Lewis was a person of the utmost good character and had no previous experience of being detained or arrested by the Police;
  • When Lewis had to sit school exams the following week, owing to the injury caused to his wrist by the Police handcuffs, he had to have a teacher write (or “scribe”) his answers for him, which intensified his unpleasant memories of this event;
  • That although his physical injury cleared up quickly, the psychological impact was much more long lasting, and a medical report from an independent psychologist whom I instructed on Lewis’s behalf established that he was now suffering from a phobia and depression (although his prognosis for a complete recovery was good).

Compensation for False Imprisonment: Why Even a Five-Minute Arrest Matters

The principles behind the calculation of damages for loss of liberty in our civil courts were set down in the famous case of Thompson & Hsu v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis , now almost thirty years ago. In that case the Court of Appeal acknowledged that the initial shock of an arrest, of being made a prisoner, having your liberty stripped from you was such a violation of your personal rights and integrity that even a very short period of detention should be compensated by a significant award, with every hour of detention thereafter worth progressively less and less (though never nil) as the reality of detention sank in and the infringement of your liberty became less painful. I have written about the rationale behind this case at length in a previous blog post, which you can read here. 

The Thompson Guidelines and Damages for Loss of Liberty

In the hands of a skilled, specialist lawyer such as myself, this enables a case to be built that even such a transitory period of detention as was suffered by my client in this case, should give rise to substantial damages. No loss of liberty should be shrugged off lightly, particularly if it also involves a violation of the safety and security of your home.

£5,000 Settlement Secured Against the Metropolitan Police

In light of this, I am pleased to confirm that after commencing Court proceedings on behalf of Lewis, I have recently agreed a settlement of £5,000 damages, plus legal costs, with the Metropolitan Police for his ordeal.

You can also read here, the details of another case of mine involving a man wrongfully arrested when his brother was wanted – and one in which we were successful despite there being a great deal more similarity between the brothers. 

Wrongfully Arrested? Specialist Legal Advice for Victims of Mistaken Identity

If you have been the victim of a mistaken arrest, even for only a short period of time, please contact me for expert assessment and advice in relation to your case.

My client’s name has been changed.

How you can help

This blog exists to inform, empower, and reassure people who may otherwise feel overwhelmed when dealing with unlawful police conduct. If you’ve found this article helpful or informative, I would be very grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Your support helps me continue this work and, just as importantly, helps others find reliable, specialist advice when they need it most. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Why The Police Complaints System is Failing

IOPC logo

This week’s blog post provides a short update on the case of my client Scott Barrett, and another example of why the Police complaints system just isn’t working and fails the public time and time again.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Police Brutality Against an Innocent Good Samaritan

Scott Barrett was a “good Samaritan” trying to help the Police when PC Kirkwood of Lincolnshire Police mistook him for a criminal suspect and then administered his own “old school” vigilante justice on this innocent man, by forcing him to the ground at taser point and then breaking Scott’s nose with a deliberate kick to his face.

How the IOPC Overturned Lincolnshire Police’s Initial Decision

After the Professional Standards Department of Lincolnshire Police determined that PC Kirkwood’s actions were “reasonable” and declined to sanction him in any way, I launched an appeal to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) on behalf of Scott, and got them to direct that PC Kirkwood should in fact face a Gross Misconduct hearing. I had previously had to intervene in a similar fashion in the equally egregious case of my client Shane Price (which also involved Lincolnshire Police). 

Gross Misconduct Found – But No Meaningful Consequences

Notwithstanding this, however, both Scott and I were left disappointed, as I reported in my previous post, by the fact that the Misconduct Panel refused to hear evidence from Scott himself at the hearing and, despite finding that the officer had committed gross misconduct, penalised the officer with only a “final written warning”. As it happened, by the time the Misconduct hearing finally took place, PC Kirkwood had chosen to retire from the Police – but had he remained in service, this sanction would have meant he was not dismissed and could have continued to patrol our streets and exercise Police power over civilians.

Indeed, should the officer decide to re- apply to the Police service in the future, he would not be barred from doing so.

Why I Asked the IOPC to Consider Judicial Review

As stated in my previous post, I wrote to the IOPC in the aftermath of the hearing and urged them to consider appealing the outcome by means of a Judicial Review. The response I have received is instructive as to the structural problems with the current Police complaints and misconduct system and so I will repeat it here in full –

“We have considered your suggestion and thank you for your patience in this matter.  After consideration, the IOPC Director of Oversight & Casework, David Ford, has decided it is not appropriate for the IOPC to seek permission to judicially review for a number of reasons. A summary of his rationale is set out below:

In this case, the IOPC directed the hearing, but it was not a party to the proceedings which were presented by the Appropriate Authority, and it was the role of Assistant Chief Constable Mayo supported by panel members and a Legally Qualified Advisor to decide the sanction. Having reviewed the material,  my view is that the hearing was wrong,  having found that the former officer would not have been dismissed had they still been serving. However,  in  any judicial review proceedings my disagreement with the sanction is irrelevant, and the court would only quash the decision if no reasonable decision-maker could make the same decision or it was procedurally or legally flawed.  Although I am concerned the former officer is not on the barred list and there is a possibility they could  seek employment back in policing or in a similar area, I feel that given the former officer’s age, this is highly unlikely, and additionally the information about the finding of gross misconduct should  be available to police vetting procedures (see below).

Whilst I do not for one second seek to minimise the severity of this case and the impact the former officer’s actions are likely to have had on the complainant, for the reasons given above, I have decided this is not a case where it is appropriate for the IOPC to seek to have the decision quashed. I do not however feel it would be appropriate to simply close this matter without further action.  I therefore plan to ensure the IOPC writes to the Chief Constable of Lincolnshire Constabulary, setting out the concerns about this case. We will seek confirmation that information about the case will be available in any vetting procedures should the former officer re-apply for a policing role. We will also inform the Chief Constable that I considered whether the IOPC should seek permission for Judicial Review, and that our oversight function monitor the outcomes of future IOPC directed misconduct proceedings.”

The IOPC Agreed the Outcome Was Wrong – But Could Not Change It

In summary: the IOPC agree with me – and are “concerned” by this outcome – but lack the real, direct powers needed to do anything about it. Judicial review is so often an inadequate tool to address problems in the complaint process as it is an indirect mechanism of last resort and sets that very high bar of asking whether “any reasonable decision maker” could have come to this conclusion before it can be overturned.

The Fundamental Problem with the Police Complaints System

As I have written about time and time again, the inherent problem with the Police complaints system is the fact that in even the most serious cases, the Police themselves are not only “judge, jury and (probably not) executioner” but also the investigators. The self-interest, self- conceit and tribalism of the Police will bias them towards favouring officers who are complained about over the public who are complaining and even when the IOPC acts in a truly independent manner and overturns key decisions such as the initial PSD outcome in this case (by which they attempted to completely exonerate PC Kirkwood), the matter then returns to the Police for the final decision. 

Why the IOPC Needs Greater Powers Over Police Misconduct Cases

Here, the IOPC was able to force them to produce the right finding of gross misconduct against Kirkwood, but not to force them to follow through with the correct verdict of placing him on the Police Barred List.

Or in other words, the IOPC has the power to lead the Police horse to water, but not to make it drink.

Reforming the Police Complaints Process: An Independent System Is Needed

Ultimately, I can sympathise with the IOPC decision not to pursue a judicial review, which would have uncertain prospects of success because it is a general legal mechanism of last recourse and not an efficient or dedicated solution for fixing the Police complaints system. The solution, as I have previously suggested, is to take the complaints investigation and prosecution process out of the hands of the Police and empower a truly independent and necessarily greatly expanded IOPC to deal with it themselves. Rather than the IOPC having to convince a judge that the Police decision maker acted entirely unreasonably, the decision should be being made by the IOPC in the first place. All too often at the moment, the IOPC lacks the way to do this, even when it doesn’t lack the will.

When the Police Complaints System Fails, Civil Claims Can Still Deliver Justice

Until change comes, however, victims of Police misconduct such as Scott can still rely on expert Police claims solicitors such as myself to secure justice for them through the civil claims process; because time and time again, when the complaint process fails – I succeed. 

How you can help

Every post on this blog is grounded in real cases, real experience, and a commitment to holding abuses of power to account. If you’ve taken something useful from this article, or if you wish to support that broader aim, I would be grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Each review strengthens this work and helps others in need of straightforward, specialist expertise find their way here. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Police Leadership Is Failing

The Police Leadership Commission’s latest report confirms what many victims of police misconduct have experienced for years: poor leadership allows toxic cultures to flourish. From flawed promotion systems and inadequate leadership training to a culture that discourages officers from speaking out, the report exposes systemic failings that undermine public confidence. Meaningful reform requires stronger accountability, better leadership development and senior officers who remember that the police exist to serve the public—not stand apart from it.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

This week, I want to draw attention to the report published earlier this month by the Police Leadership Commission, which I would urge everyone with an interest in the structural causes of Police misconduct to read. 

Whilst the report praises “outstanding examples of leadership” within the profession it also admits that there are “systemic causes for concern about the consistency, capability and culture of leadership across the service…leadership in policing is not consistently of a high enough standard to provide confidence and trust in the attainment of the service which the public deserves”

Almost every page of this blog is a record and indictment of those leadership failures – for “bad apples” proliferate in an orchard which is not well tended, but in which misconduct is too often obscured or excused, and toxic characteristics are enabled by poor or complicit leaders. 

Police Misconduct Starts with Poor Leadership at the Top

The IOPC has received 107 referrals involving chief officers since it was founded in 2018, leading to 78 investigations of officers of the rank of Assistant Chief Constable or higher, frequently for such grievous matters as cronyism, nepotism, abuse of position for a sexual purpose and corruption.

Broken Promotion Systems Are Undermining Police Leadership

“Promotion processes to sergeant and inspector are broken…They rely on an out-of-date exam that only half of prospective sergeants and just over a third of prospective inspectors pass…More than a fifth of new sergeants and inspectors responding to our survey said they received no formal leadership training more than two years into their role.”

The Gemma Barnes Case Shows How Poor Police Supervision Enables Misconduct

A ‘perfect’ example of the lack of good leadership at lower levels of the Police Force can be provided by the case of my client Gemma Barnes, about which I wrote earlier this month and which is now attracting significant media attention. In that shocking case of “candid camera” the officers involved in toxic behaviour and abhorrent comments are being presided over by their sergeant like the King of Misrule; it is an atmosphere totally lacking in internal discipline or respect for the public. 

Police Whistleblowers Still Fear Speaking Out

The Report also draws attention to the ways in which Police leadership enables bad behaviour by failing to set the right examples and by failing to protect those who do speak out. All too often, keeping your mouth shut and looking the other way when colleagues misconduct themselves seems like the only sensible thing an officer can do. 

“We have encountered overwhelming evidence that police personnel at all levels, even people in senior positions, do not feel able to speak up against failures and misconduct for fear of negative repercussions.”

This is a depressingly familiar echo of Baroness Casey’s findings in her 2023 report on the culture of the Metropolitan Police, where she highlighted that those who speak up “learn the hard way that there are adverse consequences for themselves, their careers and for their teams.”

The Casey Review Reached the Same Conclusions About Police Culture

My own review of the Casey report can be found here. 

Police Leadership Training Falls Far Behind the British Army

One striking statistic which the current report highlights is that 15 years after leaving Sandhurst, a Colonel in the British Army will have undertaken 72 weeks of leadership development, compared with “2 or 3 weeks” for a Chief Superintendent in the Metropolitan Police.

Mandatory Leadership Training Should Be Required for Chief Officers

A key recommendation of the report which attempts to address that issue, though it may come as a surprise to many that this is not already an essential requirement, is that all chief officers, including chief constables, should be expected to complete an annual performance review and continuing professional development training (CPD), as is the norm in the legal and medical professions. 

As one Police contributor to the Report commented – 

“As an accredited strategic firearms commander or public gold commander… I’ve got very, very strict and set accreditation CPD that I need to do every single year. If I don’t do it, I do not maintain my operational accreditation. We do not take the same approach for leadership and whilst there are good courses offered by the College [of Policing], they are not mandated. There’s no check and balance.”

Should Senior Police Officers Be Recruited from Outside Policing?

Another key recommendation for change is “a targeted direct entry scheme” to bring in “proven leaders” from other professions, such as local government and community safety, into senior and executive police officer roles. 

Why External Leadership Could Improve Police Accountability

I wholeheartedly endorse this idea, as I believe it could be a significant antidote to the huge problem of pro-Police bias within the profession and lack of empathy for and understanding of the public, borne of senior officers being for decades ‘soldiers’ on the inside of the Police ‘castle’, looking out. 

The report essentially endorses this sentiment, although its authors express themselves in rather more bureaucratic terms – 

“Senior police leaders can too often share a narrow set of experiences and values, partly as a product of a traditional and restrictive career pathway. They are not always open to challenge and new ideas, or prepared to take considered risks that could improve services.” 

Police Must Remember the Public Is Not the Enemy

I will conclude my thoughts by referring back to that comparison between the training of Army officers and senior Police officers. It is quite right that the model of Army leadership be looked at for good examples of building best practice; but my own ‘key recommendation’ for the Policing profession would be that they bear at all times, front and centre in their thinking, the truth that they are not an army and the public is not the enemy. 

Rebuilding Public Trust Requires Stronger Police Accountability

If the first thing that Police leaders did in response to this report was to open their ears fully and honestly to public complaints and make examples of, rather than try to protect, officers who abuse their powers or treat people with disrespect – then they would be at once strengthening the efficacy and moral fibre of their profession and restoring its reputation in the eyes of the citizenry of which it is supposed to be a part, not a foreign body. 

How you can help

This blog has grown through the trust of readers and clients rather than through aggressive marketing or paid promotion. If you feel this article offers genuine insight or practical value, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your feedback plays a meaningful role in helping others identify experienced, specialist advice when it counts. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Planes, Trains, and Wrongful Arrests (Part 2)

This blog post tells the story of “Sam White” (a pseudonym), a businessman who was wrongfully arrested at St Pancras International after police relied on a Police National Computer alert matching only his name to that of a wanted suspect. Despite carrying a passport that clearly confirmed a different date of birth and identity, Sam was publicly arrested, detained for around 18 hours, and subjected to fingerprinting, DNA sampling and an overnight stay in custody before officers finally accepted they had the wrong person. The case highlights the dangers of over-reliance on incomplete data matching and argues that police must exercise greater scrutiny and common sense, particularly at international travel hubs where biometric passports provide reliable identity verification. Following legal action, Sam received an apology, deletion of his biometric data, substantial damages and recovery of his legal costs.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Wrongful Arrests Caused by Police Data Errors 

This is the second of two posts intended, as we enter the ‘holiday season’ to shed light on the recurrent problem of people innocently engaging in international travel being mistaken for wanted criminals – in a data rich but often common-sense poor environment. 

Wrongfully Arrested at St Pancras Before Boarding the Eurostar – Sam’s Story

 In this case, my client was Sam White, a middle-aged businessman of good character.

 In May 2024, PC Bright of the Metropolitan Police submitted a “Wanted Suspect Circulation Form” onto the Police National Computer system (PNC).  It was recorded that the suspect had “Made threats to kill his brother whilst holding a knife”, contrary to Section 16 of the Offences Against The Person Act 1861. Although the suspect was also called Sam White, my client had a different date of birth and address, and was in no way connected with this other individual.

 A week later, my client arrived at St Pancreas International Station, intending to catch the Eurostar train to Paris for a business meeting; he went through the inspection gate, bag security check and passport check-in desk without incident, and made his way onto the busy departure concourse. However, there he was approached by PC Fletcher of the British Transport Police and asked to confirm his name, date of birth and address, which he duly did.

Public Arrest, Overnight Detention and the Human Cost of Police Error

 PC Fletcher then informed Sam that he was under arrest for “threats to kill”.  This came as such a shock to Sam that initially he thought it was some kind of prank.  However, reality tragically dawned, as Sam was escorted to the side of the concourse and PC Fletcher and his colleagues began to search his person and belongings in full view of Eurostar staff, Passport Control officers and members of the public.

Sam was told that his passport had triggered an “arrest flag”.  He was told he was going to be taken to a Police Custody unit, and after a short delay was transported to Islington Police Station, where he was handed over to the Metropolitan Police. 

Brought before the Custody Sergeant, Sam again provided his name, address and date of birth. 

 Sam explained that there had been some kind of gross mistake, but his representations were ignored.  In a very difficult situation, Sam chose not to contact his wife for fear of causing her unnecessary distress, hoping that things would surely be cleared up quickly. 

 Regrettably, they were not. Sam was forced to jump through all of the ‘criminal suspect’ hoops – having his fingerprints and ‘mug shot’ taken, as well as a DNA swab – the medical procedure which marks you out as a Police prisoner and is much more psychologically invasive than it is physically.

 Sam was then taken to a cell where he spent a sleepless night, hearing distressing noises from other cells and wondering how he could possibly be in this predicament. Sam felt that he now had no choice but to ask to speak to the duty solicitor and to call his wife to let her know where he was; however the custody staff expressed concern about Sam being allowed to call his wife given that – according to their records  – the suspect’s wife appeared to be the person who had reported the crime to the Police.  When Sam was finally allowed to speak to his wife, she was naturally devastated to learn what had happened to him.

An 18-Hour Detention Despite Clear Evidence of Mistaken Identity

At approximately 11am, some 18 hours after his arrest at the train station, Sam was finally taken for formal interview – during which time it quickly became apparent that he was not, of course, the suspect having a different date of birth and different home address (and, indeed, different middle name), and no knowledge of or connection with the alleged offence.

 Police Sergeant Berkley then made the following entry in the custody record –

 “OIC [Office in Case] has interviewed the DP [Detained Person] and its suspected but cannot be ruled out at this stage that the DP is not the SUS[PECT] circulated due to a discrepancy with the DOB. I have instructed the OIC to…get a photo of the SUS and rule this out as the DP ‘s DOB does not correlate with that of the circulated male and any other enquiries to eliminate DP I have asked for this to be done ASAP and a decision made and if so for the DP to be released without further delay”.

 Approximately an hour after his interview Sam was released and told that no further action would be taken against him; he was finally free to return to St Pancreas and catch the next train to Paris – during which journey he had to contemplate how he was going to explain to his business partners/ work colleagues what had happened to him.  

 As PS Berkley noted in a further entry in the custody record later that day –  “OIC on instruction made quick enquiries and P233886 established this was not the SUS.  DP was released at 11.59 based on the clarification from DC…which could have been conducted a lot sooner”.

Why a Biometric Passport Should Have Prevented the Wrongful Arrest

 This was something of an understatement, to say the very least.  At the time when he was first challenged on the platform at St Pancreas my client was, and was known to be, in possession of his passport as he was about to board an international train.  Given the difference in the suspect’s date of birth and Sam’s date of birth, he was, in effect, carrying a “get out of jail free” card on him had the British Transport Police at the station, or the custody staff on Sam’s arrival at Islington taken the merest step of examining that passport and comparing it to the suspect’s details on the PNC. 

 That should have been enough to secure Sam’s immediate release, as it would be unreasonable to assume that the passport was anything other than genuine; yet time and time again, this is the mistake which Police Officers make at such gateways of international travel as airports, seaports and train terminals – focusing on the matching data of a person’s name alone, whilst overlooking the fact that international travel requires full verification of date of birth in the form of a legitimate, biometric passport. This is not, therefore, a ‘variable’ data point which could be faked, in an international travel nexus, in the way that it could be faked (by the giving of an ‘alias’) in ordinary public places in which entry is not contingent on rigorous data analysis and documentary proof.  

Information Technology Without Common Sense: A Recurring Problem

 Once again, therefore, I can only describe the type of Policing that Sam was subjected to in this incident as being based on a use of “Information Technology” which largely bypasses the brain. 

 See It, Sue It, Sorted  

 Understanding my expertise in matters of this nature, Sam instructed me to act on a no win, no fee basis and I am pleased to confirm that after bringing Court proceedings on Sam’s behalf I was able to secure a substantial settlement for him from the Metropolitan Police.

 Nothing can entirely make up for the lost hours which Sam spent in that Police cell, or the memory of his public arrest at a train station (an event which may be routine for the arresting officers, but is a uniquely horrible interference in the lives of law- abiding citizens), but I am pleased to confirm that I won for him – 

  1. A letter of apology
  2. Confirmation that his biometric data from this arrest (fingerprints, photo and DNA) have been deleted
  3. A damages payment of £10,000
  4. His legal costs of pursuing the claim

 The Inspector of the “Professionalism Directorate” of the Met who wrote the letter of apology to my client acknowledged that this incident had “undermined” his “trust and confidence” in the Police.

Improving Police Decision-Making at International Travel Hubs

 In order for all of us to have the trust and confidence in the Police that we deserve, the regularity of wrongful travel arrests like this need to be substantially reduced, by officers properly scrutinising apparent data matches and exercising due caution, rather than rushing to arrest. We would not expect a Eurostar train or an international plane to depart without thorough and rigorous safety checks; the liberty of travellers and passengers deserves equal respect.

Further Reading on Wrongful Arrests at Airports, Ports and Transport Hubs

 Anyone looking for some “poolside reading” this month, might be interested in some of my previous blog posts on this very subject; though if you prefer a fictional thriller series – I don’t blame you! 

My client’s name has been changed. 

How you can help

Making specialist legal knowledge accessible is a core part of why I write this blog. If you believe that clear, independent information about police powers and civil liberties is important, I would greatly appreciate you taking a moment to leave a 5-star review. Each review helps ensure that those searching for answers can find this site — and the help they deserve. Thank you for your support.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation.

Police Wrongfully Arrest Protestor, Then Forget To Switch Her Camera Off

In 2024, my colleague John Hagan wrote a series of guest posts on this blog highlighting the problematic Police mentality which leads to serial acts of abuse of power towards non-violent protestors, activists and campaigners across a wide spectrum of social and political issues. 

All too often, rather than acting as even-handed referees of the law, Police Officers fall into an “us verses them” mindset as regards protestors, and John compared this to a “Blue team” versus “Red team” approach, in which Police prejudice against and hostility to protestors spill over into civil rights abuses. A “perfect” example of this is the current case of our client Gemma Barnes, an animal rights and civil rights activist, who during a lawful and non- violent protest at a Police Station in Norwich was aggressively assaulted by a senior officer, wrongfully arrested and then maliciously prosecuted – resulting in a not- guilty verdict, of course.

Gemma’s story is powerfully told in a recent video post by Police accountability campaigner Rob Warner, who does such excellent work in this field on his “Crimebodge” You Tube Channel. One of the most striking things about this case is the fact that, as Rob highlights, the Police Officers who ‘dealt’ with Gemma ended up “bugging” themselves when they confiscated her body camera device – and then forgot to turn it off. Rob’s video, collated from that footage, lets you see and hear what happened next – in all its sleazy glory.

John has summed up his own view of the case in these terms –

“This footage shows us what goes on inside many Police Officer’s heads and behind the closed doors of the Police Station, and it is not a pretty sight. Officers can be heard describing my client as a fucking waste of space, discussing other officers attempting to generate an unsubstantiated charge against her and describing a transgender person as a “thing.” They are gleeful about the violence they have used against Gemma, a peaceful protestor, and frankly the whole atmosphere is akin to a school in which the teachers are absent and the bullies have taken over. What is perhaps equally shocking to what is revealed on the “candid camera” with which the Police recorded their sordid comments, is their behaviour in the full light of day. Sergeant Allum publicly and brutally assaulted my client with the kind of cocky impunity which is born of a Policing culture which fails to police itself. The so-called Independent Office of Police Conduct has, as usual, shown itself to be anything but independent in its assessment of my client’s case, and she will now be using the full force of the civil law to hold both Norfolk Constabulary and the IOPC to account for their egregious actions.”

If Police Professional Standards Departments (PSD) and the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) decline the opportunity to properly ‘police the Police’, as they have here, then it is down to courageous private citizens such as Gemma to take legal action against the offending Police Forces, as Gemma will now be doing with the help of specialist actions against the Police solicitors in the form of myself and John.

Gemma does not need to stand alone. Please see below links to a petition and fundraiser account which she has created in relation to this case, and consider giving her your financial as well as moral support –

https://www.change.org/p/hold-norfolk-constabulary-officers-to-account/dashboard/home?source_location=user_profile_started

https://gofund.me/016782b5f

I also suggest that you not only consider subscribing to Rob Warner’s Crimebodge channel, Crimebodge – YouTube but buying his book “Copper Stopper” which is an excellent survey of Police wrongs, and your rights, and for which I was proud to write the foreword. 

Rob’s book can be purchased here – https://starchamber.co.uk/

How you can help

I publish these articles regularly to demystify police powers and to help people understand when those powers have been misused. If this post has clarified your rights or reinforced the importance of police accountability, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your review helps point others towards experienced representation at a time when clear guidance really matters. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation.

Planes, Trains & Wrongful Arrests (Part 1)

As the busy summer travel season begins, I revisit the recurring problem of innocent travellers being wrongfully arrested because of flawed police data-matching and poor use of intelligence systems. This post tells the story of “Michael”, who was mistakenly arrested twice at UK airports after being confused with a wanted suspect who shared his name but not his date of birth. Despite obvious discrepancies, police officers relied on inaccurate alerts rather than carrying out proper checks, leading to unlawful arrests, embarrassment, distress, and financial loss. After legal action, Michael has already recovered substantial damages for one of the incidents, with a second claim ongoing, highlighting the importance of holding police forces accountable when technology is used without proper judgement.

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Wrongful Arrests Caused by Police Data Errors 

As we approach the heart, and heat, of the Summer travel season, I am revisiting in this week’s post a recurrent theme of this blog: how many times our Police Forces and other law enforcement agencies use Information Technology in an unintelligent way, data- matching without joined-up thinking, and as a consequence innocent travellers at our international airports and railways stations end up with a “passport to prison.”

Wrongfully Detained on a Plane – Michael’s Story

My client Michael, a man of good character of Nigerian heritage, flew from New York to Heathrow airport with his brother in May 2023. It was a routine Virgin Atlantic Flight, but ended in personal turbulence for Michael: after the plane had landed, an announcement was made telling all passengers to remain seated, because Police Officers were boarding the plane. A few minutes later, Cabin Crew asked Michael to come to the front of the plane; there he found several Metropolitan Police Officers waiting for him. They asked him for his passport, which he agreed to provide, entirely non-plussed about what they wanted.

Wrongful Arrest at Heathrow Airport After Mistaken Identity

The Officers then escorted Michael off the plane and into a corridor in the Terminal. There, to his absolute shock, Michael was told that he was under arrest for an offence of “aggravated burglary” – involving a stabbing –  and that he would be taken to a Police Station for interview. Bewildered, Michael asked to be allowed to use his mobile phone to prove that he was not in the area of the alleged offence on the given date, but the Officers refused to allow him access to his phone, and instead placed him in handcuffs.

Michael protested that he had been in another town at the time of the alleged offence and told the officers that he had not been arrested previously.  An officer explained that passport names and numbers are checked when entering Heathrow and that Michael’s details had come back as a “wanted male” and that they “look similar”. 

Police Officers Realised They Had Arrested the Wrong Man

However, another of the officers now commented –  “I guarantee this is the wrong male.  I said that as soon as you came off the plane”.  A second officer added “Yeah, we both looked at each other and said, I don’t think so”. The officers then held up a photograph of the wanted male next to Michael and noted that there were differences in their appearances. The officers then told Michael that the arrest was “just to rule it out” (which, it need hardly be added, is not a lawful basis for arrest).  Michael told the officers that he did not like being in handcuffs and an officer flippantly replied that he would have a “funny story” to tell in due course.

Fingerprint Check Proved Michael Was Innocent

After several minutes, an INK fingerprint device was brought and when this was used upon Michael, it showed a non-match between him and the wanted male.  My client was then de-arrested and had his handcuffs removed, having endured approximately 26 minutes of arrest in distressing and embarrassing circumstances.   The Officers told Michael that they would put a “marker” on his details to say that they had spoken to him, and that he was not the wanted man.

Michael was now free to proceed to the Arrivals hall, but with a lot of unwanted emotional baggage.

Catching the Heat at Heathrow – What Had Gone Wrong?

It is rarely straightforward to get an admission of liability out of the Police in these circumstances, and they have a tendency to hide behind the “National Border Targeting Centre” (NBTC) which is a Border Force unit which co-ordinates arrest requests and passenger identity checks. In this case, the Met asserted that they had received such an alert from the NBTC, identifying Michael as the suspect in the said offence of aggravated burglary and hence dispatched a team to arrest him upon his arrival.

National Border Targeting Centre Alerts Do Not Remove the Need for Reasonable Suspicion

An NBTC alert does not permit Officers to bypass their brains, however, and the arresting Force is still required to carry out such diligent checks as are necessary to ensure there is a reasonable basis for presuming this particular traveller is indeed the wanted suspect. The Met’s lawyers asserted that they had done just that: with reference to the suspect’s Police National Computer (PNC) record, and they determined that Michael and the wanted man were “one and the same person”, on the basis that they allegedly had the same name and date of birth.

The Police Ignored a Crucial Difference in the Passenger’s Identity

However, once I had obtained unredacted disclosure of the Met’s records – which they were initially reluctant to provide, but in regards to which I knew what I was looking for – the following facts were revealed:

  • Michael and the suspect did share the same first and surnames, but both are common Nigerian/ West African names, so that alone could never have formed a reasonable basis for arrest.
  • The alert issued by the NBTC did state that the man on the incoming plane (Michael) was the suspect in the Aggravated Burglary offence.
  • However, the alert also provided the Police National Computer reference number for the suspect’s personal profile, from which it was clear that the suspect had a different date of birth from that of Michael.
  • That difference in the dates of birth of the aeroplane passenger (Michael) and the actual suspect was known to the Met, but they proceeded to intercept and arrest Michael regardless, apparently on the assumption that he was the suspect and that for some reason he was travelling under his own name but an ‘alias’ date of birth.

Why the Arrest Was Never Based on Reasonable Grounds

This assumption was a ridiculous one, and entirely undermined any argument that the Met Officers had an objectively reasonable suspicion that my client was the suspect. International air travel must be verified by a valid passport, and we all know how rigorously that identity- regime is policed, especially for travellers coming to and from America. Unless ‘spy games’ were being played, the only reasonable presumption was this: that the man on the plane was not the suspect, because of their different dates of birth, which could not have been ‘faked’ in this very particular context.

Your Liberty Is Delayed – Lightning Strikes Twice

Unfortunately, Michael was to experience a very unpleasant form of déjà vu the following Summer, June 2024, when he arrived at Gatwick Airport with his wife, to fly to Rhodes for his friend’s birthday celebration.

Wrongfully Arrested Again at Gatwick Airport

Initially all went well, Michael and his wife passed through security and passport control and then boarded the flight. However, before the plane had begun taxiing for take- off, Michael was called to the front of the plane, and with a sinking feeling in his heart, saw that there were Police Officers waiting to ‘greet’ him there. These were officers of Sussex Police, and they informed Michael that he was “wanted”.

The Same Police Intelligence Failure Happened Twice

Unbeknownst to Michael at this stage, was the fact that, notwithstanding the ‘mistaken identity’ incident of the previous year – when the Met had promised to put a marker on the PNC to stop this happening again – the National Border Targeting Centre had again ‘matched’ Michael’s passenger data with the criminal suspect who bears the same first & surname, but has a different date of birth, and who was now wanted for nothing less than conspiracy to murder.

Michael pleaded with the officers that he had been mistakenly arrested in similar circumstances in May 2023 when he returned from America, but they tried to wash their hands of the matter by saying that they were effectively merely acting as agents for the Metropolitan Police who had put out the “wanted” marker on the suspect’s details, which the NBTC had then acted upon. My client then provided the officers with a code relating to the May 2023 incident, which he had been told to provide to Police in the event of related trouble in the future.  The officers relayed this code for urgent checks.  One of the officers commented that “this is ridiculous and embarrassing. It makes us look like idiots”.

Police Arrested Michael Despite Earlier Proof of Mistaken Identity

Nevertheless, the Officers ultimately decided to carry out their original orders, and notwithstanding Michael’s protests, the reference code he had given for the previous incident, or the evidence of his passport, they arrested him on suspicion of conspiracy to commit murder and he was taken from the plane and incarcerated at Gatwick Police Station.

Failures in Police Communication and Identity Checks

It subsequently transpired that the Sussex Police Officers had contacted the Met regarding Michael’s reference code for the previous incident, only to be told that they were unable to glean any information from it “because it was over a year old.” It also transpired that Sussex Police had not actually been issued with a photograph of the wanted man, and thus were unable to carry out a straightforward visual ID of Michael. Furthermore, the Met had erroneously informed Sussex that there was an actual Court warrant for Michael’s arrest, which was not the case. Finally, the INK machine which should have been available to check Michael’s fingerprints inside the airport was not working. None of this is the greatest advertisement for “Police Intelligence”, I am sure you will agree.

Michael Missed His Flight Before the Mistake Was Finally Corrected

At the Police Station, Michael’s fingerprints were scanned, and the penny finally dropped; Michael was clearly not the wanted man. He was de-arrested, approximately an hour and a half after he had originally been summoned to the front of the plane… but by then the flight to Rhodes, with Michael’s wife on board, had already departed, greatly adding to his anxiety and inconvenience. He had to pay for a seat on another flight the following day.

It was only after the double- whammy of this second event that Michael approached me for help and advice, and I identified that he had viable claims for wrongful arrest in respect of both incidents – including not just the duration of his loss of liberty on each occasion, but its emotional and financial consequences.  

As is par for the course, both the Met and Sussex Police initially denied liability.

Ticket to Success –  Michael’s Damages Award

Backed by my specialist knowledge and advice, Michael was confident in issuing proceedings against the Metropolitan Police Commissioner in regards to his 2023 arrest and against both Sussex Police and the Met in regards to the 2024 incident.

Compensation Recovered for Wrongful Arrest and False Imprisonment

I am pleased to report that Michael’s second plane has recently come into land: we have recovered substantial damages from the Metropolitan Police, plus legal costs, for Michael’s wrongful arrest in May 2024.

A Further Compensation Claim Against the Metropolitan Police Continues

My client’s claim for the 2023 arrest, against the Met, is still ongoing, but I am confident that will have an equally satisfactory conclusion, and that Michael will end up with far more than just the “funny story” the officer suggested.

Can You Claim Compensation for a Wrongful Airport Arrest? 

I myself have another story to tell of an innocent international traveller who enlisted my aid to win justice, this time after an arrest at a railway station, which I will return to in next week’s post.

In the meantime, I wish you all safe and happy journeys wherever you may be bound this month.

My client’s name has been changed.

How you can help

I publish these articles regularly to demystify police powers and to help people understand when those powers have been misused. If this post has clarified your rights or reinforced the importance of police accountability, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your review helps point others towards experienced representation at a time when clear guidance really matters. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation

Andy Burnham’s Agenda: The Perspective of a Police Misconduct Lawyer

Photo of a judge.

Andy Burnham’s victory in the Makerfield by- election has set him on seemingly inevitable course for the biggest constituency of all – the UK, as our next Prime Minister, and the tame surrender of Sir Keir Starmer (perhaps he will return to his former field of practice in civil liberties actions – watch this space) means that he is likely to assume the ultimate leadership mantle within weeks. 

Our new PM will have a lot on his agenda, and don’t worry, I’m not going to turn this into a political blog-space (we’ve got enough of those), but I want to make a serious point about something that really matters to the clients I represent and which has been overlooked by successive governments since 2013. It is about the exposure of litigants in Police claims to the risk of having to pay the Defendant’s legal bill if they lose, and what can be done to minimise or even eliminate those risks, allowing meritorious claims to be fought without the worry of financial catastrophe for the Claimant. 

The Problem: The Financial Gamble of Litigation

 In 2018 I wrote a blog post about access to justice in civil claims, in particular, the introduction of the “Qualified One Way Costs Shifting” rules or “QOCS”, set out at 44.13 – 17 of the Civil Procedure Rules.

 The Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO), which paved the way for QOCS, effectively abolished the rights of Claimants in civil litigation to take out “After the Event” legal expense insurance products to protect them from having to pay the swingeing legal costs which Defendants are entitled to if the claim fails (on the principle of the loser in litigation having to pay the victor’s costs). I say effectively abolished, because it was still legal for claimants to take out such insurance products – it was just that their right to recover the cost of that insurance from the Defendant if they, the Claimant, won was removed, leaving litigants with the prospect of paying more for an insurance premium than their claim was worth; insurance premiums in my specialist area of claims against the Police could easily amount to £40,000 if the case went all the way to trial. Clearly that was no longer an economically viable model. 

Recognising that this change might significantly harm access to justice i.e because people would be scared away from pursuing meritorious claims because of the financial costs of either an irrecoverable premium, or the Defendant’s legal bill if they didn’t have insurance cover and ended up losing the case, the government introduced a special allowance for claimants in personal injury matters and that was Qualified One Way Costs Shifting. In essence, QOCS means that a losing Claimant doesn’t have to pay a victorious Defendant’s costs, unless the claim is found to have been “fundamentally dishonest”. 

The key problem in my area of law, however, was that the government, in its wisdom, restricted QOCS to personal injury claims – excluding claims for hugely significant civil liberty breaches, such as False Imprisonment, Malicious Prosecution, Trespass to Land and breaches of the Human Rights Act 1998. A cynic might note that whereas the paying party in the majority of personal injury claims are private insurance companies, who now had to swallow the costs of unsuccessful claims against them, the government departments and agents of the state who are the usual Defendants in civil liberties claims – including, of course, the Police – were allowed to retain the ability to pursue unsuccessful litigants for their costs, often amounting to tens of thousands of pounds. This is a significant financial “truncheon” which lawyers representing our Chief Constables are more than happy to brandish in order to ‘scare’ off potential claimants. 

As I highlighted in my previous blog post, the injustice of a situation in which those whose fundamental civil liberties have been violated face greater financial hurdles to accessing justice than do those who’ve been involved in a minor accident, was stark, and did not go unremarked upon. Indeed, a Civil Justice Council report highlighted this issue in March 2016, in strident terms:

“There are strong, if not compelling, arguments of principle –based on access to justice and on the asymmetry of the relationship between the parties – weighing in favour of extending the scope of QOCS protection (or something very similar) to claims against the police…Principled arguments for not doing so do not appear to have been made out.”

And yet, 10 years and almost sixPrime Ministers later, nothing has changed and the QOCS rules remain unaltered.  

The Solution: Playing your Cards Rights

 In reality, Britain’s new Prime Minister is going to have enough unpalatable problems home and abroad to deal with over the remaining duration of this parliament, to get around to blowing the cobwebs off that Civil Justice Council recommendation. But that doesn’t mean that those contemplating the financial risks of a claim against the Police need to despair; there are a number of ways to obviate the risk which I, as a specialist in actions against the Police (and State authorities generally) can guide you to and through. 

The first is the continued availability of legal aid for claims against the Police, the Ministry of Justice and other government departments and agencies. My firm, DPP Law, is one of those niche firms with a franchise in civil legal aid and we can offer the legal aid representation which many other lawyers cannot. Legal Aid is subject to means testing, but if you have a meritorious claim and you meet the financial criteria, I can secure a public funding certificate for you from the Legal Aid Agency. Not only does this cover your own legal costs (meaning you would not have to pay the “success fee” of up to 25% from your damages, which is generally charged under a “No Win, No Fee” arrangement) it also crucially means that you are protected from having to pay the Defendant’s costs if you lose. The best shield for any claimant is to have a legal aid certificate covering you all the way to trial; not everyone can forge that shield for you, but with the right material, I can. 

The second is the understanding and application of case law, which has continued to develop over the last ten years, even if the underlying legislation has not changed; that is, of course, the essential hallmark of the British legal system at its best: the combination of statute law (made by politicians) and case law (made by judges) – flexibly complimenting and enhancing one another and thereby the rights of the citizen. 

It is possible to bring claims against the Police within the protection of QOCS if the case is presented and evidenced in the right way. For example, if you have a claim for wrongful arrest which involves the use of force and/or psychological suffering being inflicted upon you – these are personal injuries and if they represent a significant enough proportion of the damages being sought and/or are shown to be sufficiently intertwined with other aspects of the claim (such as damages for enduring loss of liberty, or trespass to your land and property) then the right legal argument can win you full QOCS protection. 

The question of how the Court should apply QOCS to a “mixed claim” involving not just personal injury but other remedies and classes of damage, was first substantially addressed by the Court of Appeal in the 2019 case of Brown v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2019] EWCA Civ 1724. 

In that case, the Court of Appeal stated, in essence, that where there is a ‘mixed’ claim for both personal injury and non- personal injury damages and remedies, the Judge dealing with the case must exercise his discretion as to what extent it is fair to allow the Claimant (if he loses the claim) QOCS protection, in full or part. 

The Court of Appeal stated that:

“the fact that QOCS protection would have been available for the personal injury element of the claim will be the starting point, and possibly the finishing point too, of any exercise of the judge’s discretion on costs. If the proceedings can fairly be described in the round as a personal injury case then, unless there are exceptional features of the non-personal injury claims…I would expect the Judge deciding costs to endeavour to achieve a ‘costs neutral’ result through the exercise of discretion. In this way, whilst it will obviously be a matter for the judge on the facts of the individual case, I consider it likely that, in most mixed claims of the type that I have described, QOCS protection will – in one way or another – continue to apply.”

 Since the Brown case, the High Court has awarded 100% QOCS costs protection to claimants against the Police in a number of high- profile cases. 

For example, in the case of Afriyie v The Commissioner of Police of the Metropolis [2023] EWHC 1632 (KB) the Claimant was claiming not only basic damages for personal injury but also misfeasance in public office and aggravated and exemplary damages. The Judge granted Mr Afriyie 100% QOCS protection as the case was “in the round” a personal injury claim and the grounds for aggravated and exemplary damages arose from the same activity of the Police as gave rise to the personal injury claim. 

Likewise, in the case of ALK and Another against The Chief Constable of Surrey Police [2025] EWHC 1964 (KB) two Claimants who brought “mixed claims” against the Police for both unlawful arrest and the psychiatric injury caused by those arrests, were found to be entitled to 100% costs protection. 

In Summary: Ensuring Access to Justice 

Although reform of the QOCS rules to extend costs protection to all claims against the Police whether they involve personal injury or not (no ifs, no buts) is long overdue, and is clearly in the interests of justice, I do not expect our new Prime Minister to have it anywhere near the top of his agenda, if, indeed, it is even in his contemplation. But as I have hopefully outlined above, there is no need for despair as there are a number of routes through which justice can be accessed with no or minimal costs risks for Claimants. 

I am here to put my expertise at the disposal of those with meritorious claims, and help shield them from adverse costs through the application of the Legal Aid system and/or my knowledge of the caselaw in regards to this crucial issue. 

The PM’s constituency is the country; and mine is the cohort of its citizens who have been the victims of Police misconduct and abuse of power. Whatever our politicians do, I will strive to do what I can as a lawyer, to spread access to justice far and wide, through education, advice and advocacy.

How you can help

This blog exists to inform, empower, and reassure people who may otherwise feel overwhelmed when dealing with unlawful police conduct. If you’ve found this article helpful or informative, I would be very grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Your support helps me continue this work and, just as importantly, helps others find reliable, specialist advice when they need it most. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he has successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales challenging abuse of power and securing rightful compensation