
In this week’s blog post, I explain how a series of errors by the Electronic Monitoring Service and Surrey Police led to my client’s wrongful arrest and detention for an alleged breach of bail. Despite the original breach notification having been withdrawn, police officers arrested him, causing considerable distress. Following our investigations and legal proceedings, Surrey Police agreed to pay £5,000 in compensation plus legal costs, highlighting the serious consequences of administrative failures and poor communication within the criminal justice system.
Electronic Monitoring Service and Police Errors Lead to Another Wrongful “Tag” Arrest
This week’s blog concerns a case in which a person whose bail conditions were being monitored by an electronic “tag” device lost his liberty as a result of human error and lack of joined up thinking – reminding us once again that technology is only as good as the human beings at either end of it.
Electronic Tagging in the UK: How Bail Conditions Are Monitored
In the UK criminal justice system, a “tag” is a colloquial term for an electronic monitoring device, usually worn around a person’s ankle, which enables the authorities to monitor their compliance with conditions imposed by a court or other lawful authority, such as the Prison or Probation Service. In that sense, it is a descendant, in this digital age, of the “ball and chain.”
Electronic tagging is used principally in three circumstances:
- Bail: To monitor compliance with conditions imposed on a defendant released on bail, such as a curfew or geographical exclusion requirement.
- Sentencing: As part of a community order or suspended sentence order, for example to monitor compliance with a curfew requirement.
- Release from prison: To monitor compliance with licence conditions or conditions of early release, including Home Detention Curfew.
GPS and Radio Frequency Tags: Understanding the Difference
There are two principal types of electronic monitoring:
- Radio-frequency (RF) tagging: Usually monitors whether a person is present at a specified address during prescribed hours. It does not ordinarily provide continuous location tracking.
- Global Positioning System (GPS) tagging: Records the wearer’s geographical movements and can be used to enforce exclusion zones, location restrictions or other conditions.
News reports this very week suggest that Thomas Markle, father of Meghan the Duchess of Sussex, has been detained in Florida for allegedly removing just such an “ankle monitor”. The case I am about describe to you concerns a profoundly unfair detention, in which the fault lay with those policing, not wearing, the device.
Wrong Electronic Tag Fitted Following Magistrates’ Court Bail Hearing
On 7 August 2025, my client Curtis attended a hearing at Guildford Magistrates’ Court for a criminal matter. At the end of the hearing, he was granted bail with a residence and curfew condition.
On 8 August 2025, representatives from the Electronic Monitoring Service (EMS) – that ‘franchise’ of the criminal justice system currently administered by the private company Serco, attended Curtis’s home to fit a monitoring device: however, apparently because of unclear instructions from the Court, they fitted the wrong type of device – a GPS rather than a Radio Frequency tag.
I am duty bound to report that Serco’s maladministration of the EMS is nothing new – exactly the same catalogue of clownish errors occurred when the service was in the hands of their predecessors Capita Plc, leading me to ‘christen’ it the “Electronic Mistake Service”.
Electronic Monitoring Service Errors Lead to a False Breach of Bail Report
On 19 August 2025, the device showed as being of low battery. Serco issued a Section 9 Breach Notification statement to Surrey Police in respect of this on 21 August 2025.
Serco subsequently realised that they had fitted Curtis with the wrong type of device; on 31 August 2025, they emailed Surrey Police to inform them that the Section 9 statement should be “rescinded” and no action taken. The following day, Serco representatives attended my client’s property in order to change the device from a GPS model to a RF model.
Surrey Police Arrest Innocent Man Despite Withdrawal of Bail Breach Notification
Notwithstanding this, on the morning of 2 September 2025, PC Crowley and several other officers of Surrey Police arrived at Curtis’s house and arrested him for “breach of bail.” Curtis’s representations as to the true state of affairs, and the fact that the device had been changed only the previous evening, fell on deaf ears.
Wrongful Arrest and Detention Cause Distress to My Client
Upon arrival at the Police Station, Curtis made the same representations to the Custody Sergeant as he had to PC Crowley. Upon noticing the visible distress that my client was in, the Sergeant asked PC Crowley to verify the breach with EMS.
According to the custody record, the circumstances of arrest were that:
“The tagging company has informed that there has been a breach of tag and that the tag has been left uncharged for 16 hours”.
Curtis requested to be seen by a health care practitioner due to a worsening of his mental health brought on by this situation. In the meantime, he was processed and placed into a cell where he remained for several hours.
Eventually, at approximately 13:00, Curtis was released from his cell and told that there had been a mistake on the part of Serco. He was then escorted home, distraught and on edge as result of his experience.
Can Police Lawfully Arrest Someone for Breach of Bail Based on Incorrect Information?
When Curtis subsequently instructed my expert team and I to pursue a claim for wrongful arrest on his behalf, we were initially met with robust denials of liability from both Serco and the Police. Serco hid behind the fact that they had not actually arrested or detained Curtis; the Police hid behind the initial breach notification from Serco sent on 21 August, maintaining that it gave their front- line officers “reasonable suspicion” to arrest in accordance with Section 7(3) of the Bail Act 1976, and claimed not to have received any further message from Serco ‘countermanding’ this.
Challenging Surrey Police’s Defence of Reasonable Suspicion Under the Bail Act 1976
Surrey Police’s response cited the low threshold of “reasonable grounds for suspicion” set out by Lord Devlin in Hussein v Chon Fook Kam (1970) AC 942:
“Suspicion in its ordinary meaning is a state of conjecture or surmise where proof is lacking: I suspect but cannot prove…it means there is an executive discretion. In the exercise of it many factors have to be considered besides the strength of the case. The prevention of further crime and the obstruction of police enquiries are examples of those factors.”
If patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel, “Chon Fook Kam” is ordinarily the first refuge of the Police lawyer. They further pointed out that there are no “necessity to arrest” criteria applicable under the Bail Act, as opposed to a general arrest under the Police & Criminal Evidence Act, meaning that the arrestee has one less line of defence for his liberty than would ordinarily be the case.
Liability for all heads of the claim presented was therefore denied by all parties; it seemed as though the Police and Serco were happy to play a game of “tag – you’re it” between each other, in which my client would be the ultimate loser.

Missing Emails Expose Failures in Police and Electronic Monitoring Service Communications
However, my team continued to do their due diligence on behalf of Curtis, and obtained the various emails from Serco to the Police which constituted both the breach report and the breach recission. In response and following investigation, the solicitors for Surrey Police asserted that the email address used by Serco was invalid and therefore not received. However, this gave rise to an interesting question: if Surrey Police had not received the rescind request, how was it possible they had received the breach report initially? We therefore pressed for clarification as regards the notifications from EMS, and Court proceedings were commenced to increase the pressure upon our opponents.
The Police now advised that their investigations had confirmed that two EMS emails had been sent by Serco to two different Police email addresses. In both instances, one email address was invalid and the other was a valid Surrey Police email address. The first Serco email had been received and was actioned. The second Serco email, the crucial communication rescinding the initial notification although sent to both the valid and invalid email address, could apparently not be traced – in other words, the Police had no idea whether it had been received or not, or possibly lost due to a systems or human error at their end.
£5,000 Compensation Secured for Wrongful Arrest Following Electronic Tagging Errors
In the circumstances, the Chief Constable’s legal team finally agreed to enter into negotiations, and my colleague Alexandra Nelmes was able to secure a very satisfactory settlement of £5,000 damages for Curtis’s wrongful arrest, plus his legal costs.
We are left to reflect on a litany of errors. Incorrect/ malfunctioning equipment installed, emails sent to the wrong address and/or ignored – demonstrating seriously inefficient processes and lack of smart management, in which people’s liberty is left to fall down the cracks between the various bodies of a dysfunctional criminal justice system.
How you can help
Making specialist legal knowledge accessible is a core part of why I write this blog. If you believe that clear, independent information about police powers and civil liberties is important, I would greatly appreciate you taking a moment to leave a 5-star review. Each review helps ensure that those searching for answers can find this site — and the help they deserve. Thank you for your support.
Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor
Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the police. With over 30 years’ experience and a national reputation, he has successfully pursued claims against all 43 police forces in England and Wales, securing compensation for victims of wrongful arrest, unlawful detention and police misconduct. He is committed to holding the police to account and protecting individuals whose rights and liberties have been infringed.























You must be logged in to post a comment.