
This week’s blog post tells the story of my client Michael, an innocent family man who was wrongly arrested at his home in the early hours after North Yorkshire Police failed to carry out the most basic identity checks. Despite obvious differences between Michael and the actual suspect, including a 15-year age gap, he was detained, fingerprinted and transported between police stations before the mistake was finally recognised. Following a lengthy and initially dismissive police complaints process, serious failings were acknowledged, and I successfully secured over £14,000 in compensation for his unlawful arrest and detention, plus legal costs.
Content Authenticity Statement
100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.
£14,000 damages for Mistaken Identity Arrest
This week’s blog post concerns yet- another wholly avoidable “mistaken identity” arrest, arising out of lazy and slip-shod “by the numbers” Policing – in which Police “intelligence” was used with anything but, even when those numbers didn’t add up.
Police Mistaken Identity: How an Innocent Man Became a Stalking Suspect
My client Michael was at the time of these events in 2025, 41 years of age, and resided in North Yorkshire with his wife and two young children. He is a man of the utmost good character.
In April 2025, South Yorkshire Police (SYP) sent an email to their colleagues in North Yorkshire Police (NYP) requesting an “address check” on Michael’s home address – they were looking for a person who shared Michael’s first and surname, and who was suspected of “stalking his ex- partner” – but evidently did not know where this other person lived, as the email stated that the premises were only “a possible link to the suspect.” They had obtained Michael’s address from the Electoral Register. The suspect’s date of birth – which was certainly not identical to my client’s – was also provided by SYP.
SYP further informed NYP that if the suspect was indeed at the premises then “he will need arresting on suspicion of stalking” and provided details of the dates of the phone calls said to constitute this stalking.
Subsequently, two officers of North Yorkshire Police attended at Michael’s home and spoke to his wife, who confirmed that a man with the name and surname they were enquiring about did live here, and that she was his wife. One of the officers immediately replied that he was “not convinced we’ve got the right address here.” Michael’s wife confirmed that he was at work, and asked the nature of the officers’ enquiry. The same officer again replied to the effect that they were dealing with a matter for another Force, that they had “done research” but were “not overly convinced” that they “were in the right place” or that their “information is correct”.
Although she remained in the dark about what they wanted – indeed, from their comments, the officers themselves didn’t really seem to know what they wanted – Michael’s wife helpfully provided them with his phone number, and they then left.
Michael was naturally both confused and concerned when his wife then rang him at work to explain what had happened. Like a good citizen, Michael then left work early and proactively attended his local Police Station – only to be told that there was no record of why Officers wanted to speak to him. He also called the Officers on the contact number they had provided to his wife, but to no avail.
Wrongful Arrest at 2.30am: North Yorkshire Police Arrest the Wrong Man
Despite not knowing anything about why the Police were trying to reach him, Michael had really done his best to save both himself and the Police all the harm, heartache and wasted time, money and resources of a mistake and unnecessary arrest. Sadly, North Yorkshire Police were not on the same page.
That very night, at approximately 2.30am, Michael’s wife woke him in a state of alarm, saying she could hear noises outside: it was indeed “Blue Burglars.” Michael rushed down to answer the door, dressed only in his night-clothes, and was confronted by two NYP officers, including PC Potts – not the same pair his wife had dealt with earlier.
Michael explained that he had been trying to make contact with the Police “all afternoon”. PC Potts explained that he was not aware of that, but that he and his colleague had been asked to attend and speak to Michael. Michael invited the Officers into the premises, as courteously as he could do in the circumstances, and understandably anxious that neither his neighbours nor his children be woken.
Unlawful Arrest: Police Fail to Explain the Grounds for Detention
PC Potts then crashed a horse-and- cart through the dictates of both common sense and lawful Police procedure: he summarily announced that Michael was now under arrest “on suspicion of stalking” and that “South Yorkshire have basically asked us to come here and arrest you”. Michael was completely shocked and replied “stalking?” and then “who?”. PC Potts replied “I can’t give you that information, all I know is that there’s an allegation that you’ve been stalking someone. They’re purely named as victim on the log that’s been transferred from South Yorkshire”.
PC Potts failed to ask Michael to confirm his date of birth and further, failed to give any detail as regards the alleged offence and thus prevented the Claimant from understanding the basis of his arrest or asserting/ proving his innocence.
In a classic “I’m just following orders” manoeuvre, PC Potts explained that my client would have to come with the Officers to Custody and that “South Yorkshire will come and deal with you at some point and all will be explained in interview. They’ll explain the allegation”.
This failure to provide basic information about the arrest actually rendered it unlawful from the outset – but Michael did not know that. He compliantly and respectfully accompanied the officers, although he first of all had to endure the humiliation of dressing and then using the toilet whilst being supervised by one of the officers – as well as the worrying about the knock- on effect this was going to have upon his wife and children.
Detained, Fingerprinted and Transferred: The Consequences of a Mistaken Identity Arrest
Michael was then taken from his house to the distinctly unhomely surroundings of York Custody Centre.
The Custody Record stated that Michael had been arrested for “Stalking without fear/alarm/distress” and that the arrest circumstances were that “between 19 February and 18 April 2025, DP [the Detained Person] has made a call every day to the victim from a withheld number, with the intention of causing her distress. Victim has identified the DP’s voice on the calls”. The reason arrest was deemed necessary was to “allow the prompt and effective investigation, protect a child or other vulnerable person”.
Michael advised the Custody Sergeant that there had been a mistake and that he had no knowledge of, or any possible connection with, any stalking offence. However, his protestations were ignored.
Following this, Michael was obliged to remove his clothing and wear police issue clothing. Furthermore, he was required to provide his fingerprints, a DNA sample and be photographed. This is the degrading “prisoner- lite” processing which all arrestees go through; making even the most innocent feel somehow stained with guilt. Even when you are released the ‘avatar’ of yourself as a criminal suspect, with all of your biometric data, lives on in the Police computer system – and may come back to haunt you even after your innocence has been proven; so here is another reminder to exercise your rights to delete that data if you prove your arrest to have been an unlawful one.
At 4.50am, Michael was then transported to Doncaster, and handed over to South Yorkshire Police.
Wrong Person Arrested: A Simple Date of Birth Check Exposes the Police Error
Only now did an officer – the SYP Custody Sergeant in charge of “receiving” Michael – take the elementary investigative step of checking my client’s date of birth against that of the man who was actually wanted: they did not match, whereas Michael is a 41 year old Yorkshire man, the actual suspect was a 26 year old Irishman.
In the circumstances, SYP now refused to take custody of Michael, and authorised his immediate release, with the Sergeant noting his Custody Record as follows –
“DP is alleged to have stalked his ex-partner, however looking at the crime, the DOB is wrong, the wrong person has been presented to me. I am refusing detention”.
Shortly before 6.00am, Michael was released and given a lift home, feeling both emotionally battered and completely bemused by this experience of Police investigative incompetence.

Police Complaints: North Yorkshire Police Fail to Acknowledge an Unlawful Arrest
The final sour icing on the cake, however, was provided 7 months later by the response of North Yorkshire Police to Michael’s heartfelt complaint.
Entirely missing the true point of the complaint i.e his entirely avoidable and unnecessary arrest, a woeful case of “mistaken identity” and the trauma and distress this had caused to his wife as well, DCI Page addressed his response as if the only issue was the early hour of Michael’s arrest –
“There are sometimes operational reasons why arrests are made ‘out of hours’. I will ensure feedback is provided to our teams regarding appropriate timings for arrests. Your understanding is greatly appreciated.”
DCI Page was reminded of real issues at the heart of Michael’s complaint, but frankly couldn’t seem to have cared less. His response was simply an attempt at deflection and discouragement – “If you are making a complaint against false arrest etc then this will have to be put in writing to Legal Services”.
Police Professional Standards Investigation Confirms Serious Failures in Arrest Procedure
Thankfully, Michael was not discouraged, and his persistence paid off when, after a further 6 months of investigation, DC Townsend of North Yorkshire Police Professional Standards Department concluded as follows –
“Within approximately one minute of arriving at the address, PC Potts exercised his power of arrest. Critically, he failed to verify the date of birth of the individual encountered before taking that action. Such a check would have been both straightforward and necessary. The suspect sought by South Yorkshire Police was a 26 year old male born in 1998. The Complainant was significantly older, being born in 1983, and was clearly established at the address with his wife and children. PC Potts identified that he had a vehicle with a private plate. Both his appearance and personal circumstances were plainly inconsistent with the details of the suspect recorded within the investigation. These factors should have prompted immediate scrutiny and raised serious doubt as to whether he was the individual sought. It is clear that PC Potts had not taken sufficient time to review the available information. This is reinforced by the fact that he is unable to name the victim. These details should have been relayed to [Michael] at the custody desk for him to understand the offence to which he had been arrested.
The position was further exacerbated during the custody process. Prior to presenting the Complainant to custody, PC Potts obtained and recorded his date of birth. This should have brought the discrepancy to his immediate attention. Had the information contained within the originating report been properly considered, the appropriate course of action would have been to de-arrest the Complainant without delay and return him to his family.
Following the Complainant’s transfer to South Yorkshire Police, it was quickly established that the wrong individual had been arrested. Unlike North Yorkshire, South Yorkshire Police appropriately reviewed the available information, declined to authorise detention, and ensured the complainant’s immediate release. A request was then made for North Yorkshire Police to facilitate his return home.
At that stage, the complainant had been arrested from his home during the early hours of the morning, removed from his family, transported to York and then later transported again to Doncaster Custody by South Yorkshire Police, in a cage at the back of a police vehicle, and subjected to a wholly avoidable ordeal. The response from North Yorkshire Police upon being informed of the error lacked the degree of ownership, empathy, and remedial action that the circumstances warranted. Greater urgency and professionalism should have been demonstrated in addressing the consequences of the mistake and ensuring the complainant’s welfare. The facts are clearly documented and did not require much time or consideration to understand, however were not only missed by North Yorkshire officers, but again by the collecting team from South Yorkshire Police upon [Michael’s] collection.
While it may be argued that communication between the involved forces could have been clearer, the essential facts were available and readily identifiable within the information provided to the arresting officer. The key details, including the suspect’s date of birth, were plainly recorded and should have been considered before any arrest was made.”
False Imprisonment and Police Misconduct: Lessons from an Avoidable Arrest
Let me set out here the lessons to be learned from this case, that can benefit both the Police and the Public –
- There existed no reasonable grounds to arrest my client for the offence of stalking; the suspect was 26 years old and had an Irish accent. Michael was 41 years old with a Yorkshire accent. The arresting Officer failed to take obvious investigative steps that would have swiftly confirmed that my client was not the suspect including checking the suspect’s recorded date of birth against our client.
- This was then compounded by the Custody Sergeant’s failure to do his job properly; he is supposed to be an inquisitive “gatekeeper” properly scrutinising the legality of each proposed detention, not a bored bureaucrat simply rubber- stamping each arrival. My client was detained in police cells without any proper evidential basis and despite the obvious mismatch in biographical details.
- This, as NYP PSD belatedly acknowledged, prolonged an ordeal that could and should have been brought swiftly to an end. This incident did not just impose a severe emotional cost upon Michael and his family – it was a huge and self- imposed waste of Police time and resources (across two Forces).
- NYP then committed the usual Police sin of trying to brush a complaint under the carpet – it took them over a year to properly acknowledge their mistakes and wrongdoing.
- Attitudes and mindsets are the fundamental problem here, and a lack of critical thinking: arresting officers need to acknowledge the huge personal responsibility upon them not to take away a person’s liberty if it can be avoided, rather than just looking at an arrest as another task to be completed; custody sergeants need to critically and independently examine each proposed detention; Police complaint handlers need to be “on the side” of the complainant until there is evidence to the contrary (in the same way they would treat a victim of crime), they need to adopt an open, not obstructionist approach.
£14,000 Compensation for Wrongful Arrest and Mistaken Identity
I am pleased to confirm that I have recently settled Michael’s claim for over £14,000 damages, plus legal costs.
However, whilst the type of Police attitudes to the job which I have highlighted above persist – including inadequate review of available information, insufficient verification of identity, and a lack of critical scrutiny during the custody process – mistaken and entirely avoidable arrests of innocent individuals are going to continue to regularly occur. The Police need to not just pay lip- service to the need for “organisational learning” about incidents like this, but truly take these lessons into their hearts and minds.
Until they do, I will be here to assist the victims of mistaken identity arrests such as Michael, to restore the balance of justice through compensation claims and continue to highlight these cases on this blog, to ensure they get the public attention they deserve.
My client’s name has been changed.
How you can help
I publish these articles regularly to demystify police powers and to help people understand when those powers have been misused. If this post has clarified your rights or reinforced the importance of police accountability, please consider leaving a 5-star review. Your review helps point others towards experienced representation at a time when clear guidance really matters. Thank you.
Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor
Iain Gould is a specialist solicitor in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police, with over 30 years of experience and a national reputation. Having successfully sued all 43 police forces in England and Wales, he has extensive experience in challenging unlawful arrests and police misconduct. If you have been wrongly arrested, including as a result of mistaken identity or a failure by officers to properly investigate the facts, Iain can help you hold the Police accountable and secure the compensation you deserve
























You must be logged in to post a comment.