Professionals or Predators? Prison Officer Brutality

The state of Britain’s prisons is very much in the news at the moment, as the country awaits to see how a new government will address the huge problem of overcrowding, and this has prompted me to reflect on one of my cases which revolved around abuse within the prison system – perpetrated by staff against inmates.

Sometimes there are criminals on both sides of the cell door, and even in these modern times it remains the case that there is a certain corrupt cohort of Prison Officers who like to work out their power-fantasies and sadistic urges upon the Prison inmates – because who would believe such ‘second class’ citizens, who are often already vulnerable due to mental health issues and who are, of course, stigmatised, if not despised by the general population because of their criminal convictions?  

Content Authenticity Statement

100% of this week’s blog post was generated by me, the human.

Vicious and Unprovoked Assault at HMP Nottingham

My client Rick was an inmate at HMP Nottingham when he suffered a vicious and unprovoked assault from three Prison Officers.

Rick was unhappy about a decision to transfer him to another Prison and when four Prison Officers entered his cell and started collected his belongings, he verbally protested about the transfer.

At that point, Prison Officer A grabbed Rick by the head and pulled him downwards.  When Rick reacted to this by pulling away and straightening up, Prison Officer B stepped forward and punched my client twice in the head.  In self-defence, Rick lashed out and struck Officer B himself in the face.

Prison Officer C then grabbed hold of Rick from behind, and as Rick struggled against his grasp, Officer B threw a further punch at Rick – but in fact missed, and instead struck Officer C in the face. 

All of this was witnessed by the fourth Prison Guard, Prison Officer D, who did nothing to protest or intervene on my client’s behalf.

Assaulting a Handcuffed Inmate Inside a Prison Cell

Considerably distressed and alarmed by what was being done to him, Rick sat down on the bed and said that he would now agree to the transfer and would leave the cell.  Nevertheless, Officers A and B then took hold of Rick’s arms and Rick felt Officer B applying pressure to his left hand, causing him significant pain and discomfort.

Officer B then shifted his application of force to Rick’s right thumb, again causing him significant pain.

The Prison Officers then handcuffed Rick, with his hands behind his back, and then – appallingly – continued their assault.

With Rick now helplessly handcuffed, Prison Officer B struck Rick in the head several times before twisting his head and pressing a knuckle into each of Rick’s temples in turn, causing him further pain. 

Rick was then dragged to the ground by the Officers and his forehead scraped the floor.

Officer B then lifted Rick up by the handcuffs, pulled Rick’s vest up and used what appeared to be his keys to scratch the bottom of Rick’s back, causing cuts and scratches. 

Rick was then pulled to his feet, although pressure was applied to keep him bent over with his head downwards, and he was marched out of the cell.  By this time, he was bleeding from a cut above his right eye.

After briefly seeing a healthcare nurse – who deemed him ‘fit for transfer’ –  Rick was placed into a van and transported to the other Prison.

Medical Evidence Confirming Severe Injuries

I subsequently obtained Rick’s medical records from the other Prison (HMP Stocken) which showed that on his arrival that day he had a laceration to his right eyebrow, a red mark on his forehead, swelling to his right temple, red marks on both of his wrists, swelling to the back of his left hand and several scratches on his lower back – consistent with his account of the violence he had suffered.

False Testimony and the Wrongful Conviction of an Inmate

However, the four Prison Officers who had been present in his cell at HMP Nottingham subsequently made witness statements in which they falsely alleged that Rick was the aggressor and that it was Rick who had punched Officer C in the face, breaking his nose.  In fact, Officer C’s nose had been injured when Officer B, attempting to hit Rick, had missed and struck his colleague.

As a result of these false accusations, Rick was charged with causing Actual Bodily Harm to Officer C, contrary to Section 47 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861 and was convicted of this offence at a Magistrates Court Trial at which all four Prison Officers gave false testimony against him. 

Crown Court Appeal Quashes Unlawful Conviction

Rick subsequently lodged an Appeal and at the Crown Court, and on the day of the Appeal Hearing it was revealed to him by his barrister that at least two of the Officers involved in this incident had been recently suspended on suspicion of assaulting other prison inmates.  In the circumstances, the Crown Prosecution Service no longer chose to oppose Rick’s appeal and the wrongful conviction against him was quashed. 

Failure of Criminal Prosecution Against Corrupt Prison Officers

The four Prison Officers involved were all subsequently interviewed by the Police on suspicion of assaulting Rick and perverting the course of justice (in regards to the statements they had made which had led to Rick’s wrongful conviction). 

Sadly, possibly because of bias against Rick as a person with a criminal record and a history as a Prison inmate, he did not get the result he deserved from the Criminal Justice system despite a lengthy Police investigation. None of the Prison Officers involved were ever prosecuted for the assault they had perpetrated upon Rick – although they were subject to disciplinary investigations which led to all bar one of them leaving the Prison Service.

Over £20,000 Compensation Secured Against the Ministry of Justice

However, I was nevertheless able to bring successful Court proceedings against the Ministry of Justice (who were responsible for the actions of the Prison Officers) and won a substantial settlement of £20,816 plus legal costs for Rick.

Institutional Corruption and Power Behind Closed Doors

Probably the most shocking feature of this case overall is the conspiracy element – the ‘code of dishonour’ which leads Prison Officers to look the other way from, or indeed to join in, acts of bullying and violence committed by their colleagues – and the apparent sense of impunity which these types of corrupt Officers have, which lead them to commit their offences in front of witnesses (or, indeed, in this case, collaborators).

Prison Officers are properly empowered by Section 8 of the Prison Act 1952 to have “all the powers, authority, protection and privileges of a constable.” 

The flip side of that, however, is the attraction of the job to the bullies, predators, authoritarians, and abusers who seek Uniformed Power in all its several guises; and it is against such characters that our prison system must be guarded, all the more so in its current time of overstretch and crisis.  

Personal details have been anonymised.

How you can help

Every post on this blog is grounded in real cases, real experience, and a commitment to holding abuses of power to account. If you’ve taken something useful from this article, or if you wish to support that broader aim, I would be grateful if you could leave a 5-star review. Each review strengthens this work and helps others in need of straightforward, specialist expertise find their way here. Thank you.

Contact the Expert Police Misconduct Solicitor

Iain Gould is a solicitor specialising in complaints, claims and civil actions against the Police and state authorities, including the Ministry of Justice. With over 30 years of experience and a national reputation, he holds officers and custodians accountable for abuse of power, excessive force, and wrongful prosecutions, securing rightful compensation for victims of state misconduct.

Author: iaingould

Actions against the police solicitor (lawyer) and blogger.